In Flyerland, we talk a lot about grocery stores, so this question has come up before. What brought it up most recently was the Wall Street Journal story (warning: paywall) about Whole Foods opening a store in Detroit, Michigan.
He said that the company's move signals a willingness to test out markets, something that might bode well for Midtown in the future. He does not, however, think a Whole Foods in Midtown would make it.
Another coworker — who, by the way, likes the Union Kroger — thinks Midtown would definitely support the market.
For my part, I don't know. This is not a copout, an attempt to be democratic or unbiased. I simply don't know.
One point that has always been brought up (and this is pre-Journal story) lands on the won't-make-it-side, and it is that the Squash Blossom-turned-Wild Oats on Union was absorbed into the East Memphis location that eventually became Whole Foods. The reason given, per this Daily News article was declining sales.
It's worth noting, though, that this was more than a decade ago, and both buying and eating habits have changed. Witness the wealth of farmers markets that have opened in this area in just the past few years.
Now let's get back to that Memphis/Detroit connection. It's important to recognize that this is Detroit's first Whole Foods.
And there's this from the Real Estate section of the Whole Foods site:
If you have a retail location you think would make a good site for Whole Foods Market, Inc., please review the following guidelines carefully for consideration:
• 200,000 people or more in a 20-minute drive time
• 25,000-50,000 Square Feet
• Large number of college-educated residents
• Abundant parking available for our exclusive use
• Stand alone preferred, would consider complementary
• Easy access from roadways, lighted intersection
• Excellent visibility, directly off of the street
• Must be located in a high traffic area (foot and/or vehicle)
Do these "considerations" essentially disqualify Midtown? Is the East Memphis Whole Foods too central? Is there a space for a store? Do Midtowners fit the demographic?
For my part, if a Whole Foods were to open in Midtown, you would see me there with my reusable totes.
There's another scenario that I would support — a locally owned Miss Cordelia's-like market.
(Before it's brought up … I do know that there are grocery stores in Midtown. I shop at them. I also frequent Miss Cordelia's as well as the Fresh Market, Whole Foods, and Krogers in East Memphis. And, yes, I do remember Square Foods. I went to the Overton Square location a lot, less frequently the one in Cooper-Young. What I'm talking about is a place to get both your tofu and your toilet paper.)
So, now I'm asking you that hypothetical question: Would a Whole Foods make it in Midtown? Why or why not?