Exit Fields? Pity the Shelby County Democrats, if you will. They just barely managed a show of unity two months ago after the election of a new chairman (compromise candidate Matt Kuhn) amid a three-way power struggle. And in a special election two weeks ago, they held on to John Ford's old state Senate seat by the squeaker margin of 13 votes for Ford's sister Ophelia.
Now they have new worries. Richard Fields, an influential Democrat who won a seat on the party's executive committee back in July, is in danger of losing it this month. The reason? Lawyer Fields has had the temerity to provide pro bono representation to Republican Terry Roland in Roland's ongoing legal challenge to Ophelia Ford's victory, which was formally certified Monday by the county Election Commission along 3-2 party lines.
In doing so, Fields may have transgressed against party bylaws. Or so maintains fellow committeeman Del Gill who has filed a resolution forcing a vote on whether to expel Fields at next week's regular monthly meeting of the executive committee.
Gill's resolution, which chairman Kuhn has agreed to put on the next week's regular agenda of the executive committee, would present Fields with three choices:
1) He can "repudiate his support" of Roland and "dissociate his legal representation."
2) He can voluntarily resign from the committee and remain a "bona fide Democrat."
3) He can face a committee vote to remove him, which, if successful, would cause the term "none bona fide Democrat" to be attached to his name.
Gill's co-signers on the resolution include William Larsha, Derrick Harris, and party vice chair Cherry Davis. More importantly, a brief survey of opinion indicates that he may have at least the tacit support of a broad array of Democrats, cutting across the usual party dividing lines.
The local party bylaw, Article III, cited by Gill could be subject to some legal parsing, however. While it prohibits, on pain of expulsion, "supporting candidates running against Democrats in General Elections," either financially or otherwise, it makes no specific reference to legal representation.
Enter Loeffel. A month or two back, Debbie Stamson, an assistant and protégé to retiring Shelby County clerk Jayne Creson, was attending a meeting of the Shelby County Commission and wondered out loud if commission member Marilyn Loeffel still harbored ambitions of running for Creson's job next year.
At the time, the commissioner, though not a signatory to the anti-term-limits suit pressed by three of her colleagues, must surely have been wondering if the courts would permit her to run again, if she chose to, in her Cordova district. So far they hadn't, and, when asked, Loeffel confirmed that she had an undiminished interest in running for the clerk's position.
That was despite the fact that Stamson had just held a well-attended monster fund-raiser at the Germantown home of supporter Wayne Mashburn, son of semi-legendary former clerk "Sonny" Mashburn.
Loeffel was undeterred by that show of force. The commissioner, who was first elected in 1998 on a tide of socially conservative votes, remains confident that that army will rise again to support her in what shapes up as a hotly competitive Republican primary campaign against Stamson, whose husband Steve will simultaneously be running for reelection as Juvenile Court clerk.
In her official announcement of candidacy Monday, Loeffel made brief reference to her two terms as a part-time commissioner and said: "I've chosen to ask Shelby County residents for the opportunity to serve them in a full-time capacity."
Meanwhile, sometime radio talk-show host and former City Court clerk candidate Janis Fullilove looms as a potential Democratic opponent for either Loeffel or Stamson.
Enter Thaddeus. Another entry in next year's political sweepstakes is broadcaster/blogger Thaddeus Matthews, the scourge of numerous politicians, including all members of the Ford family and, from time to time, Mayor Willie Herenton.
Matthews announced last week that he would seek the District 3 County Commission seat now held by the outgoing Michael Hooks, who has the misfortune of being both term-limited and indicted in the Tennessee Waltz extortion scandal.• Gibbons fund-raiser: District Attorney General Bill Gibbons filled the upstairs room at the downtown Rendezvous restaurant Tuesday night for a fund-raiser/reception that drew many of Gibbons' fellow luminaries in addition to a large crowd of other supporters.
Among those attending in support of Gibbons' 2006 reelection effort were both Memphis mayor Herenton and Shelby County mayor A C Wharton. Reaffirming his previously announced endorsement of Gibbons, the often-controversial Herenton joked, "I hope I do him more good than harm." • It only hurts when he laughs: At a fund-raiser here last week at the home of city councilman Jack Sammons, Governor Phil Bredesen kept a smiling and relaxed demeanor despite the presence across the street of demonstrators protesting his paring of the TennCare rolls, a move he has defended as necessary for budgetary reasons.
"Inviting me is one way to get demonstrators to show up at the end of your driveway," joked the governor, who said he had spoken with several of the protesters and urged the attendees at the fund-raiser to do so. "These are good people," he said.• Focus on lobbyists: The governor's appearance in Memphis came at the end of a day in which the members of his recently appointed Citizens Advisory Panel on Ethics held the last of several statewide meetings at the University of Memphis' Fogelman Center.
Presided over by former state attorney general Mike Cody and former state senator Ben Atchley of Knoxville, the meeting was attended by several local legislators, including state senators Steve Cohen of Memphis and Roy Herron of Dresden and state representatives Paul Stanley and Brian Kelsey of Germantown and Dolores Grisham of Covington.
Cohen called for ratcheting up the current "cup-of-coffee" law to eliminate all lobbyist-funded favors for members of the General Assembly -- a point that was seconded by Stanley and Kelsey. Asked how much legislation was initiated by lobbyists rather than members of the Assembly, Cohen answered bluntly, "Almost all of it."
Grisham, who said she and two other relatively short-term Republican legislators shared the services of a single staffer, called the absence of adequate staffing for legislators "unacceptable." It meant, she said, that increasingly legislators are forced to use lobbyists as sources of advice on legislation. "The good ones will give you both sides," she said.
Current lobbyist and former legislator Rufus Jones of Memphis got the day's best laugh when asked what the duties of a lobbyist were.
"The first thing you've got to do is get a client," Jones said. "You can go up there and lobby all day long, but if you don't have a client, you're in trouble!"
The panel is scheduled to report its recommendations to Bredesen this week.• Taking the bitter with the sweet: Two Tennesseans hopeful of advancing themselves politically faced criticism last week.
Ninth District congressman Harold Ford Jr., who aspires to the U.S. Senate, was named "worst black congressman" by the "CBC Monitor," a group that performed an analysis of the voting records of members of the Congressional Black Caucus. Ford was assigned a 5 percent satisfactory rate on nine selected "bright line" issues, including his vote for the stringent bankruptcy bill passed by Congress this past spring.
Tennessee senator Bill Frist faces insider-trading inquiries from both the Justice Department and the Securities and Exchange Commission concerning his sale of Hospital Corporation of America stock just before it took a nosedive on the stock market.
HCA was founded by Frist's extended Nashville family, but Frist has said he had "no information about HCA or its performance that was not publicly available," and supporters maintain that his action was related to a need to avoid potential conflicts of interest prior to his presidential run.

Exit Fields?
Pity the Shelby County Democrats, if you will.
They
just barely managed a show of unity two months ago after the election of a new
chairman, compromise candidate Matt Kuhn, amid a three-way power struggle,
and in a special election two weeks ago, they held on to John Fords
old state Senate seat by the squeaker margin of 13 votes for Fords sister
Ophelia
Now they have new worries. Richard Fields, an influential Democrat who won a seat on the partys executive committee back in July, is in danger of losing it this month. The reason? Lawyer Fields has had the temerity to provide pro bono representation to Republican Terry Roland in Rolands ongoing legal challenge to Ophelia Fords victory, which was formally certified Monday by the county Election Commission along 3-2 party lines.
In doing so, Fields may have transgressed against party bylaws. Or so maintains fellow committeeman Del Gill who has filed a resolution forcing a vote on whether to expel Fields at next weeks regular monthly meeting of the executive committee.
Gills resolution, which chairman Kuhn has agreed to put on the next weeks regular agenda of the executive committee, would present Fields with three choices:
(1) He can repudiate his support of Roland and dissociate his legal representation.
(2) He can voluntarily resign from the committee and remain a bona fide Democrat.
(3) He can
face a committee vote to remove him, which, if successful, would cause the
term none bona fide Democrat to be attached to his name.
Gills
cosigners on the resolution include William Larsha, Derrick Harris,
and party vice chair Cherry Davis. More importantly, a brief survey of
opinion indicates that he may have at least
the tacit support of a broad array of Democrats, cutting across the
usual party dividing lines.
The
local party bylaw, Article III, cited
by Gill could be subject to some legal parsing, however. While it prohibits, on
pain of expulsion, supporting candidates running
against Democrats in General Elections, either financially or otherwise, it
makes no specific reference to legal representation.
Enter Loeffel . A month or two back Debbie Stamson,
an assistant and protégé to retiring
Shelby County clerk Jayne Creson, was attending a meeting of the
Shelby County Commission and wondered out loud if commission member Marilyn
Loeffel still harbored ambitions of running for Cresons job next year.
At the time, the commissioner, though not a signatory to the anti-term limits suit pressed by three of her colleagues, must surely have been wondering if the courts would permit her to run again, if she chose to, in her Cordova district. So far they hadnt, and, when asked, Loeffel confirmed that she had an undiminished interest in running for the clerks position.
That was despite the fact that Stamson had just held a well-attended monster fundraiser at the Germantown home of supporter Wayne Mashburn, son of a semi-legendary former clerk, Sonny Mashburn
Loeffel was undeterred by that show of force. The commissioner, who was first elected in 1998 on a tide of socially conservative votes, remains confident that that army will rise again to support her in what shapes up as a hotly competitive Republican primary campaign against Stamson, whose husband Steve will simultaneously be running for reelection as Juvenile Court clerk..
In her official announcement of
candidacy Monday, Loeffel made brief reference to her two terms as a part-time
commissioner and said, Ive chosen to ask Shelby
County residents for the opportunity to serve them in a full time capacity.
Meanwhile,
sometime radio talk-host and former City Court clerk candidate Janis
Fullilove looms as a potential Democratic opponent for either Loeffel or
Stamson.
Enter Thaddeus.
Another entry in next years political sweepstakes is broadcaster/blogger Thaddeus
Matthews, the scourge of numerous politicians, including all members of the
Ford family and, from time to time, Mayor Willie Herenton,
Matthews announced last week that he would seek the District 3 county commission seat now held by the outgoing Michael Hooks, who has the misfortune of being both term-limited and indicted in the Tennessee Waltz extortion scandal.
Gibbons fundraiser.
District Attorney General Bill Gibbons filled the upstairs room at the
downtown Rendezvous restaurant Tuesday night for a fundraiser/reception that
drew many of Gibbons fellow luminaries in addition to a large crowd of other
supporters.
Among
those attending in support of Gibbons 2006 reelection effort were both Memphis
mayor Herenton and Shelby County mayor A C Wharton. Reaffirming his
previously announced endorsement of Gibbons, the often controversial Herenton
joked, I hope I do him more good than harm.
It only hurts when he laughs.
At a fundraiser here last week at the home of city councilman Jack Sammons,
Governor Phil Bredesen kept a smiling and relaxed demeanor despite the
presence across the street of demonstrators protesting his paring of the
TennCare rolls, a move he has defended as necessary for budgetary reasons.
Inviting
me is one way to get demonstrators to show up at the end of your driveway,
joked the governor, who said he had spoken with several of the protesters and
urged the attendees at the fundraiser to do so. These are good people, he
said.
Focus on
lobbyists. The governors appearance in Memphis came at the end of a day in
which the members of his recently appointed Citizens Advisory Panel on Ethics
held the last of several statewide meetings at the universitys Fogelman
Center.
Presided
over by former state Attorney General Mike Cody and former state Senator
Ben Atchley of Knoxville, the meeting was attended by several local legislators, including state
Senators Steve Cohen of Memphis and Roy Herron of Dresden, and
state Representatives Paul Stanley and Brian Kelsey of Germantown
and Dolores Grisham of Covington.
Cohen
called for ratcheting up the current "cup-of-coffee" law to the end
of eliminating all lobbyist-funded
favors for members of the General Assembly -- a point that was seconded by
Stanley and Kelsey.
Asked
how much legislation was currently initiated by lobbyists rather than members
of the Assembly, Cohen answered bluntly, "Almost all of it."
Grisham,
who said she and two other relatively short-term Republican legislators shared
the services of a single staffer, called the absence of adequate staffing for
legislators "unacceptable." It meant, she said, that increasingly
legislators are forced to use lobbyists as sources of advice on legislation.
"The good ones will give you both sides," she said.
Current
lobbyist and former legislator Rufus Jones of Memphis got the days best
laugh when asked what the duties of a lobbyist were.
"The
first thing you've got to do is get a client," Jones said. "You can
go up there and lobby all day long, but if you don't have a client, you're in
trouble!"
The
panel is scheduled to report its recommendations to Governor
Bredesen this week.
Taking the bitter
with the sweet. Two Tennesseans hopeful of advancing themselves politically
faced criticism last week.
9th
District congressman Harold Ford Jr., who aspires to the U.S. Senate,
was named worst black congressman by the CBC Monitor, a group which
performed an analysis of the voting records of members of the Congressional
Black Caucus. The group is apparently affiliated with the Black Commentator,
a Web site which has consistently found fault with Rep. Ford, who
coincidentally addressed the Black Caucuss annual legislative meeting in
Washington last week.
Ford was assigned a 5 percent
satisfactory rate on nine selected bright line issues, including his vote for
the stringent bankruptcy bill passed by
Congress this past spring.
U.S.
Senator Bill Frist, a presidential hopeful whose vacated seat Ford and
others will be seeking next year, faces insider-trading inquiries from both the
Justice Department and the Securities and Exchange Commission concerning his
sale of Hospital Corporation of America stock just before the stock of HCA,
founded by Frists extended Nashville family, took a nosedive on the stock
market.
Frist
has said he had no information about HCA or its performance that was not
publicly available and supporters maintain that his action was related to a
need to avoid potential conflicts of interest prior to his presidential run.
Republicans could be forgiven for indulging in some bittersweet rejoicing last week. It had been back-and-forth for most of the evening, but when the final vote was totaled last Thursday night in the District 29 state Senate special election, Democrat Ophelia Ford was ahead by only 13 votes -- count 'em, 13.
Final unofficial totals, including early voting and absentee ballots and all 60 precincts were 4,333 votes for Ford and 4,320 for Republican Terry Roland, the Millington service-station owner who had carried his unlikely underdog challenge to the very brink of success. (Perennial nuisance candidate Robert "Prince Mongo" Hodges, running as an independent, polled 89 votes, leading some to wonder if he had influenced the outcome and, if so, in whose direction.)
Understandably, Roland refused to concede, telling a group of supporters at his Millington headquarters on election night, "We're still in the race," and promising to "turn things over to the people who know how to handle things like this" -- presumably a team of political and legal advisers.
A spokesman for the Roland campaign would subsequently promise to contest the outcome, saying, "We're going to bring in a shitload of attorneys" from Tennessee and Washington. And, sure enough, as of this week, Roland's gathering battery of lawyers and political advisers was actively pursuing a challenge through various appeals to state and local election officials.
Much statewide attention had been focused on the Ford-Roland race for the light it might shed on a variety of looming political subjects: the state of the Ford-family campaign apparatus; the possible shift of power in the General Assembly, where Republicans had hoped to build on their current 18-15 majority in the Senate; the signals the outcome might send for races to come, including that of Senator-elect Ford's nephew, U.S. representative Harold Ford, Jr., now a candidate for the U.S. Senate.
Long considered a stronghold for the Ford family and for Democratic candidates in general, District 29, which hugs the Mississippi riverfront for almost the length of Shelby County, has a largely African-American population, but Roland's Republican team had put forth intense efforts, not just in his own Millington bailiwick, but, to some measurable effect, in the inner city itself.
But even as Republicans were taking heart at one of their number's showing in a predominantly Democratic district, other figures in the party were doing their best to move the GOP in an opposite direction.
There were two cases in point: one local, one statewide.
First, there was a pending change of the guard in state House District 97, soon to be vacated by incumbent Tre Hargett. Former House Republican leader Hargett ignited a storm last month by first accepting a job as chief lobbyist in Nashville for the Pfizer pharmaceutical firm, then rejecting it -- under pressure from Pfizer itself, some theorize -- when the "revolving-door" job offer became an issue in the legislature's still-festering ethics controversy.
Hargett would ultimately be offered a higher-paying job by his long-standing employer, Rural/Metro Ambulance Services, but he had meanwhile quit his leadership post and declared he would leave the legislature. Though some still believe that Hargett will reconsider and run for reelection next year, the main issue seems to be whether he will serve out his current term or resign his House seat outright, forcing the appointment of an interim successor.
If the latter turns out to be the case, both Shelby County GOP chairman Bill Giannini and other local Republicans have indicated their preference that the County Commission select a fill-in and not one of the several Republicans interested in running for the seat next year. ("I don't want to create a state representative," Giannini said bluntly this week.)
Several Republicans have signaled their intent to run for the seat, including three prominent middle-of-the-roaders -- Bartlett alderman Mike Morris, teacher/activist Jim Coley, and Shelby County school board member Anne Edmiston. Other candidates may be coming, and at least one who's already there has prompted some concern in the GOP mainstream.
That would be Austin Farley, the "Political Cesspool" broadcaster whose radio shows, like his Web site, focus on efforts, in Farley's words, "to preserve our Southern heritage and its symbols." Among other things, Farley has been a vigorous defender of the status quo in the simmering controversy over three Confederate-themed parks in downtown Memphis.
There are no runoffs in legislative races, and the more crowded the field gets, the better the chances for someone like Farley, whose hard-core constituency could give him a plurality.
Conventional wisdom, of course, holds that District 97, in the heart of Bartlett, is Republican for time to come, about as "red" on the political color chart as it's possible to be, the center of gravity for SUVs sporting the letter W. About as staunchly Republican a place, in other words, as Senate District 29 -- which just elected a candidate named Ford by 13 votes -- is staunchly Democratic.
And there's the rub. Last week's nip-and-tuck affair in District 29 is a lesson that cuts both ways, especially in special elections. If a bona fide Bubba like Terry Roland can do as well as he did in John Ford's bailiwick, then why, Democrats are beginning to ask themselves, shouldn't a Democrat be able to pull something off in Tre Hargett's?
District 97 was, after all, represented for decades by Democrats -- first Harold Byrd of the Bank of Bartlett Byrds, then his brother Dan. And there were mainstream Democrats discussing seriously last week the option of trying to talk Dan Byrd out of political retirement.
The issue of Republican identity is at stake on the statewide level, too -- notably in next year's governor's race, where Democratic incumbent Phil Bredesen's onetime aura of invincibility has been tarnished enough by the his budget-minded paring of the TennCare rolls that statewide Republicans have begun to dream of mounting a credible challenge.
Senate Republican leader Ron Ramsey of Blountville is one prospect, as is former legislator Jim Henry of Kingston, a well-liked centrist who ran for governor in the 2002 GOP primary. Most Republican hopes, though, have been vested in state representative Beth Harwell of Nashville, the former state Republican chair.
But just as the specter of Farley bedevils the mainstream Republicans of Bartlett, so, on the statewide scene, does that of one Carl "Two Feathers" Whitaker, an arch-conservative gubernatorial candidate and pillar of the Minuteman movement that has made an issue of thwarting illegal immigration from Mexico.
Whitaker claims Native American ancestry but also, as he light-heartedly told a recent meeting of the socially conservative Defenders of Freedom organization, has "some white" in him. Too much so, grumble some alarmed Republicans, mindful of several recent e-mails from Whitaker to his network of supporters alerting them to sex crimes allegedly committed by illegal aliens in Tennessee.
Though Whitaker is considered a long shot in the governor's race, to say the least, the very fact of his candidacy makes him a potential Republican nominee by default and intensifies the pressure on Harwell or some other mainstream GOP figure to declare.
The fear in Republican ranks is that anything resembling a race-based appeal could nullify the GOP's developing approach to traditional Democratic voters -- specifically to the middle-class, religiously conservative blacks so recently courted by Terry Roland and targeted for long-term outreach by Shelby County Republican chairman Giannini.
Complicating the picture is the fact that the GOP right is capable of making its own pitch to voters in the center of the political spectrum.
Republican crossover appeals have been based, locally as nationally, more on "values" issues than on economic ones, but a rough form of populism has lately begun to rear itself in the ranks of the Defenders of Freedom, a local group which occupies the rightward edge of local Republicanism and stresses religious and patriotic themes.
E-mailing his local network this week, DOF founder Angelo Cobrasci announced a memorial service for a man who, he said, had died after losing his TennCare prescription-drug benefits "as a result of these draconian cuts by Governor Phil Bredesen." And he wondered: "How many more?"
For that matter, when Whitaker himself addressed a meeting of the DOF a few weeks ago, he began his speech with solicitous-sounding reflections on the TennCare crisis.
Which is to say, the crossover lanes potentially run in more than one direction, for Republicans as well as for Democrats, and the two-way traffic could generate as many potential hazards as benefits.
This project is going forward, said Governor Phil Bredesen to tumultuous applause Thursday night. The subject was a proposal for state funding to begin the process of transplanting the law school of the University of Memphis to a downtown location, upgrading it in the process.
The audience which heard this happy news, at a fundraising event for Bredesen at the East Memphis residence of city councilman Jack Sammons, included many representatives of the University of Memphis, who hatched the relocation project earlier this year in an effort to shore up the schools long-term accreditation.
The American Bar Association had put the university on notice that its present law school facilities on Central Avenue were considered inadequate.
The move, into the landmark Post Office building on Front St., which would be extensively renovated for the purpose, would ultimately cost some $41 million, said Law School dean Jim Smoot, one of several university officials to have lobbied the governor on the point.
I think this is what you call a full-court press, said the governor about the university groups efforts.
Bredesen kept a smiling and relaxed demeanor despite the presence across the street of demonstrators protesting his paring of the TennCare rolls, a move he defended again Thursday night as necessary for budgetary reasons.
Inviting me is one way to get demonstrators to show up at the end of your driveway, joked the governor, who said he had spoken with several of the protesters and urged the attendees at the fundraiser to do so. These are good people, he said.
The governors appearance in Memphis came at the end of a day in which the members of his recently appointed Citizens Advisory Panel on Ethics held the last of several statewide meetings at the universitys Fogelman Center.
Presided over by former state Attorney General Mike Cody and former state Senator Ben Atchley of Knoxville, the meeting was attended by several local legislators, including state Senators Steve Cohen of Memphis and Roy Herron of Dresden, and state Representatives Paul Stanley and Brian Kelsey of Germantown and Dolores Grisham of Covington.
Cohen called for ratcheting up the current "cup-of-coffee" law to the end of eliminating all lobbyist-funded favors for members of the General Assembly -- a point that was seconded by Stanley and Kelsey.
Asked how much legislation was currently initiated by lobbyists rather than members of the Assembly, Cohen answered bluntly, "Almost all of it."
Grisham, who said she and two other relatively short-term Republican legislators shared the services of a single staffer, called the absence of adequate staffing for legislators "unacceptable." It meant, she said, that increasingly legislators are forced to use lobbyists as sources of advice on legislation. "The good ones will give you both sides," she said.
At one point, panelist Lyle Reid, the former chief justice of the state Supreme Court, probed into the basic function of lobbyists. Among those called upon to answer was current lobbyist and former legislator Rufus Jones of Memphis, who provided one of the afternoon's best laugh lines.
"The first thing you've got to do is get a client," Jones said. "You can go up there and lobby all day long, but if you don't have a client, you're in trouble!"
The panel will shortly report its findings and recommendations to Governor Bredesen.
New problems for Dixon
One of the former legislative figures whose indictment in the recent Tennessee Waltz scandal was a major reason for the ethics panels creation took another jolt on Thursday.
That came when assistant U.S. Attorney Tim DiScenza announced that former state Senator Rosce Dixon was subject to indictment and prosecution on matters unrelated to his previously alleged extortion activities in relation to the bogus FBI company eCycle Management. Dixon was forced to resign as an aide to Shelby County mayor A C Wharton when he was indicted on the eCycle matter in late May.An obviously shaken Dixon told reporters Thursday that the government holds all the cards and you get to spread your arms and get nailed to the cross. It certainly appeared that the government had stepped up its pressure on Dixon possibly to encourage a plea change on the prior charges.
But neither Dixon, who had said only last week that he was wiling to stand trial on the eCycle charges, nor his attorney, Walter Bailey, indicated that any change was likely in Dixons existing Not Guilty plea.Gibbons fundraiser
District Attorney General Bill Gibbons filled the upstairs room at the downtown Rendezvous restaurant Tuesday night for a fundraiser/reception that drew many of Gibbons fellow luminaries in addition to a large crowd of other supporters.
Among those attending in support of Gibbons 2006 reelection effort were both Memphis mayor Willie Herenton and Shelby County mayor Wharton. Reaffirming his previously announced endorsement of Gibbons, the often controversial Herenton joked, I hope I do him more good than harm.
In his remarks, Gibbons compared his efforts to punish the guilty and to protect the innocent to law-enforcement measures pursued in New York City in the 90s under the administration of then Mayor Rudy Giuliani.
Republicans could be forgiven for indulging in some bittersweet rejoicing last week. It had been back-and-forth for most of the evening, but when the final vote was totaled last Thursday night in the District 29 state Senate special election, Democrat Ophelia Ford was ahead by only 13 votes count em, 13.
Final unofficial totals, including early voting and absentee ballots and all 60 precincts were 4333 votes for Ford, and 4320 for Republican Terry Roland, the Millington service-station owner who has carried his unlikely underdog challenge to the very brink of success. (Perennial nuisance candidate Robert Prince Mongo Hodges, running as an independent, had polled 89 votes, leading some to wonder if he had influenced the outcome and, if so, in whose direction.)
Understandably, Roland refused to concede, telling a group of supporters at his Millington headquarters on election night, Were still in the race, and promising to turn things over to the people who know how to handle things like this" -- presumably a team of both political and legal advisers.
A spokesman for the Roland campaign would subsequently promise to contest the outcome, saying, "We're going to bring in a shitload of attorneys," both from Tennessee and Washington. And, sure enough, as of this week, Rolands gathering battery of lawyers and political advisers were actively pursuing a challenge through appeals of various sorts to both state and local election officials.
Much statewide attention had been focused on the Ford-Roland race for the light it might shed on a variety of looming political subjects: the state of the Ford-family campaign apparatus; the possible shift of power in the General Assembly, where Republicans had hoped to build on their current 18-15 majority in the Senate; the signals the outcome might send for races to come, including that of Senator-elect Ford's nephew, U.S. Rep. Harold Ford, Jr. , now a candidate for the U.S. Senate.
Long considered a stronghold for the Ford family and for Democratic candidates in general, District 29, which hugs the Mississippi River-front for almost the length of Shelby County, has a largely African-American population, but Roland's Republican team had put forth intense efforts, not just in his own Millington bailiwick but, to some measurable effect, in the inner city itself.
BUT, EVEN AS REPUBLICANS were taking heart at one of their numbers showing in a predominantly Democratic district, encouraging thoughts of future crossover appeal, other figures in the party were doing their best to move the GOP in an opposite direction.
There were two cases in point: one local, one statewide.
First, there was a pending change of the guard in state House District 97, soon to be vacated by incumbent Tre Hargett. Former House Republican leader Hargett ignited a storm last month by first accepting a job as chief lobbyist in Nashville for the Pfizer pharmaceutical firm, then rejecting it under pressure from Pfizer itself, some theorize when the revolving-door job offer became an issue in the legislatures still-festering ethics controversy.
Hargett would ultimately be offered a higher-paying job by his long-standing employer, Rural/Metro Ambulance Services, but he had meanwhile quit his leadership post and declared he would leave the legislature. Though some still believe that Hargett will reconsider and run for reelection next year, the main issue seems to be whether he will serve out his current term or resign his House seat outright, forcing the appointment of an interim successor.
If the latter turns out to be the case, both Shelby County GOP chairman Bill Giannini and other local Republicans have indicated their preference that the county commission select a fill-in and not one of the several Republicans interested in running for the seat next year. (I dont want to create a state representative, Giannini said bluntly this week.)
Several Republicans have signaled their intent to run for the seat, including three prominent middle-of-the-roaders -- Bartlett alderman Mike Morris, teacher/activist Jim Coley, and Shelby County school board member Anne Edmiston. Other candidates may be coming, and at least one whos already there has prompted some concern in the GOP mainstream.
That would be Austin Farley, the Political Cesspool broadcaster whose radio shows, like his Web site, focus on efforts, in Farleys words, to preserve our Southern Heritage and its symbols. Among other things, Farley has been a vigorous defender of the status quo in the simmering controversy over three Confederate-themed parks in downtown Memphis. There are no runoffs in legislative races, and the more crowded the field gets, the better the chances for someone like Farley, whose hard-core constituency could give him a plurality.
Conventional wisdom, of course, holds that District 97, in the heart of Bartlett, is Republican for time to come about as red on the political color chart as its possible to be, the center of gravity, locally, for SUVs sporting the letter W. About as staunchly Republican a place, in other words, as Senate District 29, which just elected a candidate named Ford by 13 votes, is staunchly Democratic.
AND THERES THE RUB. Last weeks nip-and-tuck affair in District 29 is a lesson that cuts both ways, especially in special elections. If a bona fide Bubba like Terry Roland can do as well as he did in John Fords bailiwick, then why, Democrats are beginning to ask themselves, shouldnt a Democrat be able to pull something off in Tre Hargetts?
District 97 was, after all, represented for decades recently by Democrats first Harold Byrd of the Bank of Bartlett Byrds, then his brother Dan. Just in case, there were mainstream Democrats discussing seriously last week the option of trying to talk Dan Byrd out of political retirement.
The issue of Republican identity is at stake on the statewide level, too notably in next years governors race, where Democratic incumbent Phil Bredesens onetime aura of invincibility has been tarnished enough by the his budget-minded paring of the TennCare rolls that statewide Republicans have begun to dream at least of mounting a credible challenge.
Senate Republican leader Ron Ramsey of Blountville is one prospect, as is former legislator Jim Henry of Kingston, a well-liked centrist who ran for governor in the 2002 GOP primary.
Most Republican hopes, though, have been vested in state Representative Beth Harwell of Nashville, the former state Republican chair who is presumed acceptable to both moderates and conservatives and until recently was a candidate for the U.S. Senate.
But just as the specter of Farley bedevils the mainstream Republicans of Bartlett, so, on the statewide scene, does that of one Carl Two Feathers Whitaker, an arch-conservative gubernatorial candidate and pillar of the Minuteman movement that has made an issue of thwarting illegal immigration from Mexico.
Whitaker is a former independent who claims Native American ancestry but also, as he light-heartedly told a recent meeting of the socially conservative Defenders of Freedom organization, has some white in him. Too much so, grumble some alarmed Republicans, mindful of several recent emails from Whitaker to his network of supporters alerting them to sex crimes allegedly committed by illegal aliens in Tennessee.
Though Whitaker is considered a long shot in the governors race, to say the least, the very fact of his candidacy makes him a potential Republican nominee by default and intensifies the pressure on Harwell or some other mainstream GOP figure to declare.
THE FEAR IN REPUBLICAN RANKS is that anything resembling a race-based appeal could nullify the GOPs developing approach to traditional Democratic voters specifically to the middle-class, religiously conservative blacks so recently courted by Terry Roland and targeted for long-term outreach by Shelby County Republican chairman Giannini (as by his predecessor, Kemp Conrad).
Complicating the picture is the fact that the GOP right is capable of making its own pitch to voters in the center of the political spectrum.
Republican crossover appeals have been based, locally as nationally, more on values issues than on economic ones but a rough form of populism has lately begun to rear itself in the ranks of the Defenders of Freedom, a local group which occupies the rightward edge of local Republicanism and has so far stressed religious and patriotic themes.
Emailing his local network this week, DOF founder Angelo Cobrasci announced a memorial service for a man who, he said, had died after losing his TennCare prescription-drug benefits as a result of these draconian cuts by Governor Phil Bredesen. And he wondered: How many more?
For that matter, when Whitaker himself addressed a meeting of the DOF a few weeks ago, he began his speech with solicitous-sounding reflections on the TennCare crisis.
Which is to say, the crossover lanes potentially run in more than one direction, for Republicans as well as for Democrats, and the two-way traffic could generate as many potential hazards as benefits.
The District 29 special state Senate race (with apologies for those who are reading this on Friday morning or later, when Thursday's election results will be known):
For the second time in less than a year, the Shelby County Republican Party has put a major move on in a special election race taking place in a predominantly African-American, heavily Democratic district. For the second time in a year in such a race, the GOP has managed to out-poll its Democratic rivals in early-voting turnout.
Only this time, with election day coming up on Thursday, the cavalry may not arrive for the Democrats. Or so confided a ranking Democrat early this week -- either out of legitimate concern for the outcome or in an effort to drive some additional election-day votes by sounding an alarm.
In any case, Republican businessman Terry Roland suddenly seemed a real threat to steal the District 29 state Senate seat away from Ophelia Ford, sister of John Ford, the Democrat who had held the seat for 30 years before being forced to resign this year in the wake of his indictment in the Tennessee Waltz scandal.
With early voting now concluded, Roland was generally thought to own as much as a 600-vote margin over Ford. "And that's a lot to make up on election day," said the Democrat, in a convincing show of concern.
Roland has campaigned hard in his own bailiwick of Millington, one of the district's few Republican enclaves, but he has also made a point of showing up at traditional Democratic stops, even taking Sunday-morning turns in various black churches, where his down-home self-professed "country-boy" manner has found some unexpected resonance.
Roland has been assisted by the virtually invisible campaigning mode of Ophelia Ford, whom many Democrats privately see, both literally and figuratively, as a weak sister. At what should have been a climactic rally on Saturday at her Southgate headquarters, Ford attracted a small crowd of supporters that contained no office-holding members of her well-known political clan.
Former state senator Roscoe Dixon was on hand, though -- maintaining, when asked, that he would not join the parade of fellow Tennessee Waltz indictees changing their pleas from not guilty to guilty. "I'm going to stand trial," insisted Dixon, who left the Senate early this year and was succeeded by former state representative Kathryn Bowers, who was later indicted, along with Dixon, John Ford, and four others, for extortion in the scandal.
In her own special election race, back in May, Bowers faced a full-court press from GOP contender Mary Ann McNeil, who finished with considerably more than a third of the vote on election day after leading during early voting.
Ophelia Ford's final vote total might still be dramatically boosted via intervention on the part of another brother, former U.S. representative Harold Ford Sr., whose last-minute robocalls on behalf of his sister are credited with having given her a narrow win in the August Democratic primary.
Even if Roland should stage an upset, the aforementioned ranking Democrat found two silver linings: 1) that "he [Roland] would have to run again next year, and he'd lose"; and 2) that Senate Republicans, even with a strengthened majority, would not have an opportunity to replace Democratic speaker and Lieutenant Governor John Wilder of Somerville until January 2007.
Two more special elections could be coming up in Shelby County, depending on A) whether state senator Bowers is able to finish her term; and B) whether state representative Tre Hargett of Bartlett, who has resigned as House Republican leader, chooses to finish his.
Hargett recently ignited a storm by first accepting then declining the position of head lobbyist in Nashville for the Pfizer pharmaceutical firm. When his current employer, Rural/Metro Ambulance Services, offered Hargett a substantial promotion, he decided to stay with the company but reaffirmed his resignation from his leadership post. Hargett has apparently also stayed with his original decision not to seek reelection next year but hasn't decided on whether to resign his seat before then.
Several Republicans have lined up as would-be successors to Hargett: teacher Jim Coley, Bartlett alderman Mike Morris, broadcaster Austin Farley, and, most recently, Shelby County school board member Anne Edmiston, who is thought to have the inside track on an interim appointment by the Shelby County Commission if one is called for.
Cohen vs. Bredesen (cont'd.): State senator Steve Cohen upped the ante in his ongoing verbal combat with Governor Phil Bredesen Sunday, accusing Bredesen of waging "a Katrina -- a war for political expediency on poor people" by paring the TennCare rolls, a process which, said Cohen, would "deprive 200,000 people of health care and cost many of them their lives."
Speaking at a seminar on "Rethinking the War on Drugs" sponsored by the Public Issues Forum of Memphis, the Midtown Democrat also took an indirect swipe at U.S. Senate hopeful Harold Ford Jr., the Memphis congressman whom Cohen unsuccessfully opposed in the 1996 Democratic primary for the 9th Congressional District seat.
Cohen noted that no Tennessee congressman had voted for a bill in Congress that would have prevented federal law enforcement authorities from arresting medical-marijuana users in states where they were entitled to use marijuana by law. "And I submit to you that it'd be a popular thing for one of our congressmen to do, because it would say to the state of Tennessee that we had a congressman who had a brain and who had a vision and who had a heart and was trying to make a difference and not just to promote themselves to another office."
Said Cohen: "There's a purpose to being in office and that's to try to do things to make your society better and not just to advance yourself. Basically what I've seen in my life, most politicians are just there for the next office. They're there for the next fund-raiser, for the next round. And I see it when I look to Nashville, and I see it when I look to the 9th District. And it's very disheartening."
Cohen continued: "The people are so far ahead of the politicians on so many issues, it's a shame. And you don't see a whole lot of politicians put their neck out on issues to make society better. I have a lot of despair right now when I look at our president, and to be honest, when I look at our governor, who is bringing about a Katrina in Tennessee. It's just that the 200,000 people he's depriving of health care aren't put in front of The Pyramid for the public to see. They're spread out throughout this state. That is a Katrina -- a war, for political expediency on poor people who can't afford health care themselves and for the political agenda of a multimillionaire who wants to be something else in life rather than the provider and giver of health care and a better, more progressive society, but wants to advance himself."
Cohen, who is sponsoring pending legislation that would legalize medical marijuana use for specified classes of patients, appeared at the forum meeting along with Dr. Ethan Nadleman, founder and executive director of the Drug Policy Alliance, which opposes the federal "War on Drugs" as both a wrong-headed policy and a failure.
Saying, "Why am I the only council member asking questions?" City Council member Carol Chumney issued a statement late last week demanding that the administration of Mayor Willie Herenton "stop playing games" and respond to a detailed inquiry (see in full at MemphisFlyer.com) which she submitted concerning budgetary shortfalls.
Chumney also defended her attendance record, lamenting that "If I show up and speak, I'm grandstanding. If I don't show up one time for a good reason, I'm singled out for criticism."
The District 29 special state Senate race: For the second time in less than a year, the Shelby County Republican Party has put a major move on in a special election race taking place in a predominantly African-American, heavily Democratic district. For the second time in a year in such a race, the GOP has managed to out-poll its Democratic rivals in early-voting turnout.
Only this time, with election day itself coming up on Thursday, the cavalry may not arrive for the Democrats. Or so confided a ranking Democrat early this week either out of legitimate concern for the outcome or in an effort to drive some additional election-day vote by sounding such an alarm.
In any case, Republican businessman Terry Roland suddenly seemed a real threat to steal the District 29 state Senate seat away from Ophelia Ford, sibling of John Ford, the Democrat who had held the seat for a full 30 years before being forced to resign this year in the wake of his indictment in the Tennessee Waltz scandal.
With early voting now concluded, Roland was generally thought to own as much as a 600-vote margin over Ford. And thats a lot to make up on election day, said the Democrat, in a convincing show of concern.
Store-owner Roland has campaigned hard in his own bailiwick of Millington, one of the districts few Republican enclaves, but he has also made a point of showing up at traditional Democratic stops, even taking Sunday-morning turns in various black churches, where his down-home self-professed country-boy manner has found some unexpected resonance.
Roland has been assisted by the virtually invisible campaigning mode of Ophelia Ford, whom many Democrats privately see both literally and figuratively -- as a weak sister. At what should have been a climactic rally on Saturday at her Southgate headquarters, Ford attracted a small crowd of supporters containing no office-holding members of her well-known political clan.
Former state Senator Roscoe Dixon was on hand, though maintaining, when asked, that he would not join the parade of fellow Tennessee Waltz indictees changing their pleas from not guilty to guilty. Im going to stand trial, insisted Dixon, who left the Senate early this year and was succeeded by former state Rep. Kathryn Bowers, who was later indicted, along with Dixon, John Ford, and four others, for extortion in the Tennessee Waltz scandal.
In her own special election race, back in May, Bowers faced a full-court press from GOP contender Mary Ann McNeil, who finished with considerably more than a third of the vote on election day after leading during early voting in that case, largely on the strength of Republican ballots in Collierville.
Ophelia Fords final vote total might still be dramatically boosted via intervention on the part of another brother, former U.S. Rep. Harold Ford Sr., whose last-minute district-wide robocalls on behalf of his sister are credited with having given her a narrow win in last months multi-candidate Democratic primary.
Even if something like that doesnt happen and Roland should stage an upset, the aforementioned ranking Democrat found two silver linings: (1) that he [Roland] would have to run again next year, and hed lose; and (2) Senate Republicans, even with a strengthened majority, would not have an opportunity to replace Democratic speaker/Lt. Gov. John Wilder of Somerville until January of 2007.
Two more special elections could be coming up in Shelby County, depending on (a) whether state Senator Bowers is able to finish her term; and (b) whether state Rep. Tre Hargett of Bartlett, who has resigned as House Republican leader, chooses to finish his.
Hargett recently ignited a storm by first accepting, then declining the position of head lobbyist in Nashville for the Pfizer pharmaceutical firm. When his current employer, Rural/Metro Ambulance Services, offered Hargett a substantial promotion, he decided to stay with the company but reaffirmed his resignation from his leadership post. After a spell of re-thinking, Hargett has apparently also stayed with his original decision not to seek reelection next year but hasnt decided on whether to resign his seat before then.
Several Republicans have lined up as would-be successors to Hargett: teacher Jim Coley, Bartlett alderman Mike Morris, broadcaster Austin Farley, and, most recently, Shelby County school board member Anne Edmiston, who is thought to have the inside track on an interim appointment by the Shelby County Commission if one is called for.
Cohen vs. Bredesen (contd): State Senator Steve Cohen upped the ante in his ongoing verbal combat with Governor Phil Bredesen Sunday, accusing Bredesen of waging a Katrina -- a war for political expediency on poor people by his paring of the TennCare rolls, a process which, said Cohen, would deprive 200,000 people of health care and cost many of them their lives.
Speaking at a seminar on Rethinking the War on Drugs sponsored by the Public Issues Forum of Memphis, the Midtown Democrat also took an indirect swipe at U.S. Senate hopeful Harold Ford Jr., the Memphis congressman whom Cohen unsuccessfully opposed in the 1996 Democratic primary for the 9th Congressional District seat.
Cohen noted that no Tennessee congressman had voted for a bill in Congress that would have prevented federal law enforcement authorities from arresting medical-marijuana users in states where they were entitled to use marijuana by law. And I submit to you that itd be a popular thing for one of our congressmen to do, because it would say to the state of Tennessee that we had a congressman who had a brain and who had a vision and who had a heart and was trying to make a difference and not just to promote themselves to another office to do nothing except at a higher level.
Said Cohen: "Theres a purpose to being in office and thats to try to do things to make your society better and not just to advance yourself. Basically what Ive seen in my life, most politicians are just there for the next office. Theyre there for the next fundraiser, for the next round, for the next whatever. And I see it when I look to Nashville, and I see it when I look to the 9th District. And its very, very disheartening."
The full context of Cohen's remarks about Bredesen went this way: The people are so far ahead of the politicians on so many issues, its a shame, and you dont see a whole lot of politicians put their neck out on issues to make society better. I have a lot of despair right now when I look at our president. To be honest, when I look at our governor, who is bringing about a Katrina in Tennessee. Its just that the 200,000 people hes depriving of health care arent put in front of The Pyramid for the public to see it. Theyre spread out throughout this state. That is a Katrina a war, for political expediency on poor people who cant afford health care themselves and for the political agenda of a multi-millionaire who wants to be something else in life rather than the provider and giver of health care and a better, more progressive society, but wants to advance himself.
Hes going to deprive 200,000 people of health care and cost many of them their lives. Thats cruel, and its Katrina in Tennessee, and its happening now at our governors level.
Cohen, the sponsor of pending legislation that would legalize medical marijuana use for specified classes of patients, appeared at the Forum meeting along with Dr. Ethan Nadleman, founder and executive director of the Drug Policy Alliance, which opposes the federal War on Drugs as both a wrong-headed policy and a failure.
Saying,
[W]hy am I the only council member asking questions?, city council member Carol Chumney issued a statement late last week demanding that the administration of Mayor Willie Herenton stop playing games and respond to a detailed inquiry which she submitted concerning budgetary shortfalls.
Chumney also defended her attendance record compared to that of other council members, lamenting that,If I show up and speak; Im grandstanding. If I dont show up one time for a good reason; Im singled out for criticism.
Full text of Chumney statement:
WHEN WILL THE ADMINISTRATION STOP PLAYING GAMES AND ANSWER THESE SIMPLE QUESTIONS?
When the City Finance Director disclosed the new budget shortfall last month, I called for answers on the record to the questions attached to this press release. At his request for more time, Councilwoman Tajuan Stout Mitchell, chair of the Council budget committee, scheduled a meeting for Thurs., Sept. 1. I put it on my schedule and planned to attend.
Councilwoman Stout Mitchell, then cancelled the meeting without explanation on Tuesday afternoon, Aug. 30th; and the Mayor sent a letter advising that he was nominating a new Finance Director, creating the new position of Chief Financial Officer at total salary of $187,000, and reassigning the current City Finance Director.
When Councilwoman Stout Mitchell did not schedule a budget meeting for Tues., Sept. 6, a regular Council meeting day, I sent her an e-mail asking when the questions would be answered. She responded on Fri., Sept. 2, resetting the meeting for Thurs., Sept. 8, without any inquiry as to the availability of any council member to attend, or explanation as to why it was not scheduled on the regular council day.
On Tues., Sept. 6, the Mayor made an impromptu appearance at the City Council Executive Session. In response to my direct inquiry as to whether we would get the facts and accurate numbers on the budget for Thursdays budget meeting, the Mayor unequivocally stated that he would not provide numbers until they were accurate, and that would not be for some time.
Based upon the Mayors response that no answers would be forthcoming, I kept my prior commitments of a court appearance, and speaking to community leaders about government, and resubmitted my questions in writing to the budget chair. As reported on several newscasts, the administration did not answer the questions at yesterdays meeting.
Ironically, a few weeks ago, much ado was made of a Public Services & Neighborhoods meeting chaired by me on ethics reform, which no other Council member attended, and the spin was that council members did not attend in an effort to embarrass me. Yet, when no other council member but the chair attends the Budget meeting, the spin with some is that Carol Chumney wasnt there? Seems like a double standard to me, and more of the petty politics which is why government is not run efficiently and professionally at City Hall. As one of the few Council members who attended nearly every budget hearing this year, Ill match my council committee attendance record against any other Council members any day, and to imply otherwise is ludicrous.
If I show up and speak; Im grandstanding. If I dont show up one time for a good reason; Im singled out for criticism. And why am I the only Council member even asking questions? But once again, the administration gets to walk away from the real story without having to answer the real question: when will they stop playing games and answer these simple questions attached to this press release today?
TO: Tajuan Stout Mitchell, O & M Budget Chair
Members of O & M Budget Committee
FROM: Carol Chumney
DATE: September 8, 2005
RE: Report on Budget from Administration
Due to two previously scheduled commitments, I am submitting my written questions for the hearing today on the current status of the budget. I will be delayed in attending the meeting, and will look forward to listening to the Committee hearing tape to hear the administrations response to these questions:
1. At the July 26, 2005 City of Memphis Healthcare Committee Meeting, 3rd Quarter 2005, the administration presented a Financial Report that showed an 11% (over 4 million dollar) savings in comparing the citys health care costs for the 2nd quarter of 2004 versus the 2nd quarter of 2005, which includes both active and retiree employees. (see chart attached). Now the administration says that 4 million of the 10.3 million deficit is that the pensioners insurance is over budget by 4 million, with an unfavorable variance due to under budgeting. Assumption-by switching healthcare provider, we felt at the time there would be savings for General Fund. (see page 6 from City of Memphis FY 2005 Operating Update August 16, 2005 attached). These appear to be inconsistent statements, where one report states a 4 million dollar savings, and the other states a 4 million dollar unfavorable variance. Please explain.
2. Since the administration admits that most of the 10.3 million dollar shortfall was known before the proposed FY2006 budget was presented to the Council, please explain why these shortfalls were not addressed in the proposed budget at that time.
3. What is the total amount of shortfall at the present time?
4. On page 12 of the City of Memphis FY2005 Operating Update August 16, 2005, the shortfall coverage identifies three categories: (1) Personnel Attrition/Vacancies 4.3 million; (2) Operating Cost Savings- 5 million; Amnesty Program- 1 million. Please provide specifics on (1) what positions will be eliminated;(2) a list of the operating costs that will be saved for each department with the amount of savings projected; and (3) the financial documentation supporting the projected 1 million in savings from the Amnesty Program.
cc: press/media