Our scores: Elliot Yamin schleps all the way up to A+ for If I Can Dream and Trouble; Taylor Hicks gets a B- for Jailhouse Rock and In the Ghetto; Chris Daughtry a C+ for Suspicious Minds and A Little Less Conversation; and Katherine McPhee a D for off-center/over-the-top renditions of a Hound Dog/All Shook Up medley and Cant Help Falling in Love.