EVANS REVERSED IN ARENA SUIT 

EVANS REVERSED IN ARENA SUIT

The Tennessee Court of Appeals Friday reversed Chancellor Walter Evans‘ ruling and injunction against the city of Memphis and Shelby County in the NBA arena lawsuit.

The decision of the three-judge panel, which heard oral arguments Monday, is a victory for the city and county and a defeat for lawyer Duncan Ragsdale, who filed the original lawsuit. Ragsdale could still appeal to the Tennessee Supreme Court.

The appeals court said the city and county properly complied with legislation creating a sports authority and that a new arena is a valid public purpose.

”We conclude that the resolutions of the governmental entities and the contracts executed pursuant thereto are for a public purpose as construed by the Tennessee court and the decisions of courts in other states,” the judges said in a 21-page ruling.

Evans ruled in July in Ragsdale’s favor in a strongly worded ruling that took the city and county and even Ragsdale by surprise. The chancellor said there would have to be a referendum with 75 percent approval for the project as funded to proceed.

"There is every indication that the legislature intended for activities encompassed by the Sports Authority Act to be identified as a public purpose," says the appeals court ruling. "Courts are not authorized to consider whether legislation is unwise or inequitable; thus, we cannot consider the wisdom or necessity of the legislature’s policy decisions."

The court said legislators are entitled to "great deference" and that "the court should not substitute its judgment for that of the legislative body

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
    • The power of RESPONSE

      The powerful message of RESPONSE.

Blogs

News Blog

Alexander to TVA: Don't Buy Wind Power

Intermission Impossible

Hattiloo Announces Season 12: August Wilson, Lynn Nottage, Soul Train...

News Blog

Memphis Theological Seminary Stands with Refugees

News Blog

Fight Over Forrest Statue Isn't Over

Fly On The Wall Blog

Remembering the "Miracle Child" Robert Raiford

Memphis Gaydar

Bathroom Bill Halted in TN Legislature

News Blog

RIP Robert Raiford

ADVERTISEMENT

Readers also liked…

ADVERTISEMENT
© 1996-2017

Contemporary Media
460 Tennessee Street, 2nd Floor | Memphis, TN 38103
Visit our other sites: Memphis Magazine | Memphis Parent | Inside Memphis Business
Powered by Foundation