GADFLY: Why the Mayor Will Lose 

John Branston ("City Beat," July 5) says Willie Herenton will win. I say: No way. Put simply, Memphians are tired of Mayor Willie Herenton, including his shenanigans and histrionics. This is not unlike the fatigue the American public is suffering with our current president (and the members of his party), and which was substantially responsible for the transfer of power from Republicans to Democrats in our recent congressional elections.

Just like the W. in the White House, W.W. Herenton has an Iraq as well. It's called crime. Memphians are scandalized by an upsurge in violent crime in the Bluff City, a troubling trend that has placed the city in the first tier of the most dangerous cities in the country.

History has a way of showing mayors who preside over dangerous trends in their cities to the door. So too will it happen in Memphis, where -- other than calling for an unfunded, and probably unfundable, dramatic increase in the number of police -- our Mayor has done little or nothing to stem the advancing tide of criminality in our city.

The second element in Herenton fatigue is also analogous to the national scene. Memphians have watched as an arrogant, aloof, frequently disconnected mayor has launched all manner of attacks on those he perceives as his enemies. Remember: The last unhinged politician who compiled an "enemies list" was Richard Nixon, and we know how well that turned out.

Herenton attacks the media and anyone who dares speak out against him as being racist or, worse, ungodly. One need only look at the recent, surrealistic press conference conducted by the mayor in which he accused several unnamed "snakes" of mounting a campaign to unseat him. Never reluctant to play the race card when it suits him, the Mayor suggested that those out to get him were motivated by racial animus.

Never mind that the Memphis electorate (including black voters) is increasingly showing the ability to discriminate among candidates, and not on the basis of race, but on the basis of competence -- a phenomenon most vividly displayed in the elections of Steve Cohen to Congress and A C Wharton as county mayor. So where's the race card in that deck (other than the mayor's joker)?

The mayor's credibility is at an all-time low. One clear proof of that comes from the recent thumping that his man, Robert Spence, took in a race for the state senate seat vacated by Cohen. The fact that voters apparently were more influenced by a circular circulated by lead "snake" Richard Fields calling attention to Spence's shortcomings, than by Spence's close affiliation with the Mayor bodes ill for the voters' willingness to credulously accept the Mayor's conspiracy theory, and therefore for the Mayor's reelection itself.

And the ultimate factor in Herenton fatigue is doubt about his competence. Whether it's raising city property taxes to the point where Memphis enjoys the distinction of having the highest property taxes in Tennessee, presiding over a failing public school system, demonstrating the same kind of cronyism in the appointment and retention of city officials (remember Joseph Lee?), or the granting of favors to his pals like the other "W" (remember beer board baron Reginald French?), Herenton has disaffected wide swaths of the Memphis electorate, regardless of race, and several early polls (which the Mayor predictably discounted) showed that.

Finally, the one potentially superseding, intervening force that would assure Herenton's loss would come when and if Shelby County Mayor Wharton comes to his senses and realizes that the future of this city is far more important than his false sense of loyalty to a man who is dragging down both that city, and the county it sits in along with it.

I predict that sixteen years of King Willie will be end up being enough for most voters in Memphis. What's more, I also predict that black voters who are tired of being played by a mayor who, when it suits him, cozies up to the same constituency of white businessmen he now denounces will see through his latest transparent tirade and turn him out of office.

Comments (11) RSS

Showing 1-10 of 11

Add a comment | All comments »

Amen, Brother.

Posted by Wintermute on July 11, 2007 at 10:04 AM | Report this comment

Even if the voters in Memphis finally have enough of Willie, their cumulative voting power will be diluted among a sea of candidates. If we don't have a primary to narrow the field, can the candidates come together for the greater good to do it themselves? Tough times call for tough measures, and a continued dilution of the popular vote will only guarantee dubya-dubya another term.

Posted by KDub on July 11, 2007 at 10:10 AM | Report this comment

Mr. Aussenberg, Black voters do NOT need you to tell us who to support or not. You do not know us so do not try to speak for us. Hater.

Posted by lucy on July 11, 2007 at 10:48 AM | Report this comment

Apparently, Mr. Aussenberg didn't see all those anti-Herenton voters moving to Tipton, Fayette, and Desoto Counties. Herenton wins unless Wharton enters the race.

Posted by polardonkey on July 11, 2007 at 11:13 AM | Report this comment

Lucy: I'm not telling anyone how to vote, and nothing I said could be construed by any reasonable person as hate. I'm just calling it as I see it. If you want to see a hater, I suggest you look in the mirror.

Posted by Gadfly on July 11, 2007 at 11:27 AM | Report this comment

Unfortunately people like Lucy are unable to distinguish between astute political comments and simply being a "hater." That sort of divisive attitude is the problem with Memphis. Too many people of both races think that the problem is the other race. Instead of trying to figure out how to work together and fix this broken city, you point fingers and demand that "the other side" not over step its perceived boundaries. It seems to me Lucy that the "hater" is you.

Posted by Clint on July 11, 2007 at 11:27 AM | Report this comment

Extremely well written column! Unfortunately, "Lucy" is the first to cry foul because of hate......just like Herrenton will when he loses. "Lucy" please provide us with one reason you will vote for W.W. in the next election. I'm not about hate, I'm about results. Willie hasn't produced any meaningful results in a long, long time. Good luck to Mayor Wharton if he decides to enter the race. Mr. Wharton - please do not delude yourself with any misplaced loyalty to W.W. either. Rest assured he would not afford you any if the tables were turned.

Posted by j4549 on July 11, 2007 at 3:40 PM | Report this comment

What is happening in Memphis defies explanation. I've lived here with my family for only about 4 years and I can't wait to leave. Political corruption is so pervasive that no officials in the City appear to escape its powerful grasp. The real question is 'who cares?' Memphis will remain stagnate and caustic no matter who takes over the reins. This city is simply impervious to positive change. If you ask me most Memphians are haters in one way or another; each blaming the other for problems that should have been solved decades ago. Memphians oft claim to possess the higher moral authority in issues of public concern thus ensuring the lower morality of anyone who has a different view. How can a place with so many religious institutions be so allergic to fellowship? Hyperbole aside, all I can say is Good luck!

Posted by bryan56 on July 11, 2007 at 3:50 PM | Report this comment

bryan56: Your question about the correlation between religion and fellowship is rhetorical, right? Remember, there's a big difference between righteousness and self-righteousness. Senator Vitter is just the latest of many recent victims of the latter. The question now, in light of the just-announced indictments is, what will the ripple effects be, and, more importantly, will "Main Street Sweeper" be content with having swept up the crumbs.

Posted by Gadfly on July 11, 2007 at 6:14 PM | Report this comment

Screw em both. Draft Nick Clark.

Posted by Anthony on July 11, 2007 at 10:51 PM | Report this comment

Add a comment

ADVERTISEMENT

From the Archives

  • Networx: Who Knows Who in This Deal?

    And what does the public need to know?
    • Jun 14, 2007
  • Person, Former Councilman Blast Commission Court Move

    Accusing the Shelby County Commission of "political" and "disruptive" actions in voting to create a second Juvenile Court judge, Judge Curtis Person got verbal support Wednesday from former city councilman Fred Davis, who called a key commissioner "the biggest crock of crap I've seen."
    • May 31, 2007
  • More»

Author Archives

  • GADFLY: Phone THIS home, cellulistas!

    Sez the Gadfly: "For some time I've been tempted to take the unacceptability of cell phone omnipresence into my own hands."
    • Nov 23, 2009
  • GADFLY: Today's 'Cool Sounds?' Bah, Humbug!

    "As I watched the Grammy Awards the other night...I was, once again, struck by how vastly superior my generation's music was to what passes for music these days."
    • Feb 3, 2010
  • More»

Most Commented On

Top Viewed Stories

  • Harold Ford's New Wife Contributes to Tinker

    From Tennessee Politics Blog: Harold Ford Jr's New Wife Gave to Tinker.

    -- Harold Ford Jr. just got married a couple of months ago, but he's wasted no time in taking advantage of one of the main political advantages of marriage -- insulation from controversal political donations ...

    • Jul 16, 2008
  • The Big Chill

    The political air grows frigid, and it isn't just the weather.
    • Jan 21, 2010
  • More»

Site Search

ADVERTISEMENT
© 1996-2010

Contemporary Media
460 Tennessee Street, 2nd Floor | Memphis, TN 38103
Visit our other sites: Memphis Magazine | Memphis Parent | Memphis Business Quarterly
Powered by Foundation