Homebuilders' Group Calls for Rep. Blackburn's Defeat 

With a week to go before the end of voting in the August 7th Republican primary in the7th Congressional District, Tom Leatherwood's insurgent campaign against GOP incumbent Marsha Blackburn got a new boost from a traditionally Republican voting bloc. The 15 past presidents of the Memphis Area Association of Home Builders have called for Blackburn's defeat in an open letter protesting her vote against the bipartisan Housing Stimulus Act.

Text of the letter is as follows:


Fellow Members of MAHBA:

The 15 Past Presidents of the Memphis Area Association of Home Builders, whose names you find below, ask that you vote against Congresswoman Marsha Blackburn in the upcoming primary election.

When President Bush signed the Housing Stimulus Act into law, months of concerted effort by many groups and individuals culminated in an important victory for homebuilders. A victory desperately needed by those of us in the beleaguered housing industry. This piece of legislation holds real promise to revive our struggling industry and may determine whether some of the businesses which belong to our association survive the current downturn.

While we are elated at the passage of this bill we are very disappointed that Marsha Blackburn chose to vote against it and our interests. Compounding our disappointment is the fact that members of MAHBA met with Congresswoman Blackburn on numerous occasions to explain in detail our support for this legislation.

Marsha Blackburn's vote on this issue clearly demonstrates that we cannot count on her to look out for the interests of homebuilders or for those who rely upon the home building industry to earn their living. We need real friends in Congress, representatives who share our concerns and understand the importance of homebuilding to the

economy. Congresswoman Blackburn does not deserve the support or
votes of the members of MAHBA.

Please demonstrate your dissatisfaction with her vote against the Housing Stimulus Act by voting for Tom Leatherwood in the Republican primary.

Clyde Patton
Brad Rainey
Phil Chamberlain
Jerry Gillis
Ronnie Tickle
John Duke
Pat Mahoney
Paul Ryan
Bruce Upchurch
Phil Bryce
Charles Morgan
Mack Andrews
Terry Dan
Palmer Albertine
Tim Wilson


In a press release last week, Blackburn defended her vote against the measure as follows:

Blackburn Statement on Housing Bill

Bill Came With Deeply Flawed Policy and a Very High Price Tag

WASHINGTON - Rep. Marsha Blackburn (TN-7) joined every one of her Republican colleagues in Tennessee in voting against HR 3221, the Housing Rescue and Foreclosure Prevention Act of 2008. While the bill offers some assistance to homeowners and homebuilders, it also has deep flaws and an astronomic price tag.

"This was a very difficult vote for me; I agonized over it until the last minute. I know well how desperately homeowners in Tennessee need and deserve relief; I also know how urgently we need to bring stability to the housing market. Unfortunately, this bill violated almost every good government instinct in my soul. I fear that, all too soon, provisions in it will do far more harm than good and tie Congress's hands when intervention is needed most."

The bill now goes to the Senate with 152 no votes in the House, which would have been enough to sustain a Presidential veto.

What Was Wrong With The Housing Bill:

· Tax Increases. The bill contains two multi-billion-dollar tax increases and a controversial credit-card reporting provision.

· Government Sponsored Enterprise (GSE) Bailout: Congressman Blackburn believes strongly that Frannie and Freddie May must be supported, but this legislation is deeply flawed. The bailout would give the Treasury Department a blank check in a complete abdication of Congressional oversight responsibility. At the same time the bailout could put taxpayers on the hook for as much as $5 trillion dollars worth of risk - an amount larger than the economy of every single country in the world except the United States or China. This enormous federal investment in GSEs does not clearly state conditions under which the bailout is to be allowed.

· Affordable Housing Trust Fund: This new permanent funding source for federal public housing would siphon money from the financially strapped GSEs and direct it towards politically motivated advocacy groups, with no room for Congressional oversight. These groups, like La Raza and ACORN, have a history of partisan political activity and are under investigation for voter fraud, embezzlement, and other potentially fraudulent activities.

· Subprime Lender Bailout: The legislation also establishes a $300 billion program to prop up lending institutions largely responsible for the subprime crisis. In so doing, the bill allows some lenders to recoup losses by transferring liability from their riskiest loans to the federal government.

· Expanding Governments' Landlord Role: The bill also transfers $4 billion to a grant program allowing state and local governments to purchase and rehab foreclosed property, promoting government ownership of private property. This perverse provision creates new landlord roles for local and state governments, in an attempt to expand the size and scope of government.

Comments (17) RSS

Showing 1-5 of 17

Add a comment | All comments »

Tom Leatherwood now finds him in an interesting situation: If he accepts this endorsement, he would basically concede that he supported this bill, which as Blackburn's release shows is incredibly full of pork. This would be a serious blow to Leatherwood's attempts to run as an opponent of wasteful spending. If he comes out against the Housing Bill, however, he will no doubt upset the Home Builders and lose an endorsement on which the ink is not yet even dry.

Posted by Eads86 on July 31, 2008 at 3:54 PM | Report this comment

Marsha Blackburn once again made the principled choice to not support increased government and poor legislation. See the Wall Street Journal article today "Acorn Leads Drive to Register Voters Likely to Back Obama; New Federal Funds." The Democrats are the biggest beneficiaries in this deal!

Posted by TN True Conservative on July 31, 2008 at 4:39 PM | Report this comment

too bad marsha votes for all the Omnibus Appropriations bills, they make the homebuilder bill look like chump change

Posted by MickeyWhite on July 31, 2008 at 5:21 PM | Report this comment

As a new homeowner I'm glad to see Marsha stand up to the Memphis Home Builders Association, Having purchased a new home that was built with salvage lumber, shoddy construction, and sloppy workmanship,it's time for the local builders and their association to clean up their profession, along with the worthless home warranties that are offered to the un-suspecting public. If the local home builders wants to see a healthy market then perhaps it needs to take a look at what it's members are calling quality built homes backed by a warranty that protects the builder and not the homeowners. Buyer Beware of any builder that offers new construction with 2/10 Home Buyers Warranty company, have your attorney review the policy, once you sign it, you throw any legal options and the builder is counting on just that. Now is the time for the local homebuilders to do a self examination of their industry, and it's time for the builders to hold its own members accountable for the dire straights that is currently facing in the Memphis Market, and not look for a hand-out or an excuse,

Posted by RStew Hernando MS on July 31, 2008 at 8:43 PM | Report this comment

Tom Leatherwood supports the federal government giving taxpayers money to liberal groups that are supporting Barack Obama for President! After reading the Homebuilders' letter it sounds like the only reason why they are endorsing Tom over Marsha is because Marsha voted against the Housing bill and they believe that Tom would have voted for the bill. If it is true that Tom Leatherwood does in fact support the Housing bill then once again we would have to believe that he supports everything that is in the bill which would mean that he supports the provision in the bill that gives taxpayer's money to politically active groups like La Raza and ACORN which are both currently under investigation for voter fraud and embezzlement and are trying to use taxpayers money to turn the vote out for Obama. If true this wouldn't surprised me since Leatherwood has been endorsed by the Commercial Appeal, has taken money from Unions, Trial Lawyers and has teamed up with the liberal group CREW in an effort to take out the Most Conservative Woman in Congress.

Posted by Novak on July 31, 2008 at 11:52 PM | Report this comment

Add a comment

ADVERTISEMENT

From the Archives

  • McCain to Pick Fred Smith for Veep? Sez Who?

    Sez 7thDistrict congresswoman Marsha Blackburn. (Or congressman Blackburn, since, so help us, that's the title she insists on.) And the news was doled out to the nation at large last Monday night...
    • Jun 12, 2008
  • Did Trustee Bob Patterson Anoint His Own Successor?

    Two apparently evenly-matched opponents -- Democrat Paul Mattila and Republican Ray Butler -- debated Monday night for the right to succeed the late, well-liked Trustee Bob Patterson. Both are long-term associates of Patterson. But the debate revealed that the late Trustee may already have designated which of the two should hold the office.
    • Jun 9, 2008
  • More»

Most Commented On

Top Viewed Stories

Site Search

ADVERTISEMENT

Flyer Flashback

Flyer Flashback

To mark the Flyer's 20th anniversary, we're looking back at stories from our first two decades.

Read Story

© 1996-2009

Contemporary Media
460 Tennessee Street, 2nd Floor | Memphis, TN 38103
Visit our other sites: Memphis Magazine | Memphis Parent | Memphis Business Quarterly
Powered by Foundation