Letter from the Editor 

In his "City Beat" column last week, John Branston reported on a new policy at The Commercial Appeal regarding advertiser sponsorship of news and features. Editor Chris Peck calls it "monetizing content." Journalists around the country — and in the CA newsroom — are calling it a bad idea.

Posted online with John's column at MemphisFlyer.com is an internal memo from CA management outlining the new policy. Here's a sample: "Newspapers are looking for new ways to attach ads in print and online to specific stories, features, and sections. This represents a marked change from past practices. No longer are there thick, inpenetrable walls between newsroom, advertising, and circulation departments. Today ... [we] understand that our content is what makes us valuable and we want to 'put a meter' on that value."

The sound you hear is that of editors spinning in their grave.

I'm not going to pretend that editors never have to deal with helping to generate revenue. At the Flyer, we run lots of "special sections" — dining guides, gift guides, etc. — in the hopes that advertisers will buy ads because the content is relevant to their business. But that's quite different than putting a logo from, say, Malco Theatres, in the middle of Chris Herrington's film column. Such a move would call into question Chris' ability to impartially review a movie.

The CA now puts a logo from Boyle Investments and a "sponsored by" line in Amos Maki's "Done Deals" column in the Sunday paper. Does the logo alter Maki's ability to write the column objectively? Probably not. But it gives the appearance that journalism is for sale, and it devalues his work.

The issue drew national attention from journalism trade websites such as Editor & Publisher and others last week. Peck responded at length to E&P, saying future sponsorships are probable, but they would not likely be attached to what he termed "high-end pieces of journalism." (I bet that makes Maki feel good.)

But why hasn't Peck come clean with his own readers about this policy? What's "high end" journalism? What's "low end"? And how can the reader tell the difference? He's got a weekly column, after all.

Maybe he's waiting to find a sponsor for it.

Bruce VanWyngarden

brucev@memphisflyer.com

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Blogs

Politics Beat Blog

Surprises Galore at Local GOP's Lincoln Day Dinner

Film/TV/Etc. Blog

Sun Records Episode 1: A Positive Note

Exhibit M

Art Stuff To Do this Weekend

Hungry Memphis

The Beer Bracket Challenge heads to the Round of 8

News Blog

Bike, Pedestrian Projects Win $2.2M in Grants

The BruceV Blog

Your Weekly Danziger

Tiger Blue

#15 Cincinnati 87, Tigers 74

Fly On The Wall Blog

Conservatives Have an Identity Problem. It's Called Their Identity

News Blog

Start Seeing Trolleys (But Not Ride Them)

ADVERTISEMENT

More by Bruce VanWyngarden

Readers also liked…

  • Lightning Strikes

    It's deep in a November night in Memphis, and I'm awakened by rain. It's coming down hard, sounding like a million pebbles hitting the roof. The gutter I've been meaning to clean is overflowing outside the bedroom window. A flash of lightning illuminates the room, and I do what I've done since I was a boy: count the seconds 'til the thunder rolls. I get almost to 10 before I hear a distant rumble. Two miles or so. Someone else's lightning ...

    • Nov 19, 2015
  • Zooey and Bowie

    Time moves in one direction, memory in another. — William Gibson

    This week, an old friend sent me a photo of myself, circa 1978. In the picture, I was thin, long-haired, and standing barefoot on the porch of an old farmhouse where we lived, just outside of Columbia, Missouri. It was a shock to see it. I don't remember my friends and I taking many photographs, and I didn't remember this moment ...

    • Jan 14, 2016
  • The Winds of War

    "Nice little trees you got there. Be too bad if something were to happen to them." — Nicky "Big Panda" Flacco, Memphis Zoo press secretary ...
    • Jan 21, 2016
ADVERTISEMENT
© 1996-2017

Contemporary Media
460 Tennessee Street, 2nd Floor | Memphis, TN 38103
Visit our other sites: Memphis Magazine | Memphis Parent | Inside Memphis Business
Powered by Foundation