A watered-down version of Commissioner Steve Mulroy's proposed antidiscrimination ordinance was passed by the County Commission on Monday but only after several days of public histrionics. Commissioner Wyatt Bunker and six local ministers held a demonstration downtown and trotted out the usual fear-mongering. They said if the law passed, gays couldn't be fired for cross-dressing or using the opposite gender's restrooms. They said that homosexuality is a sin and that gays are trying to force their "agenda" on God-fearing Christians. And they reiterated the threadbare argument that being gay is a choice, not an inherent trait, such as black skin or blue eyes.
These folks are on the wrong side of history — and of science and common decency. Even if you grant them the absurd notion that being gay is a choice, their argument against job protection still falls flat. You "choose" to be Presbyterian or Muslim or a Republican, and those choices are protected by law. So why shouldn't your "choice" to be gay be protected? It's legal to be gay, after all.
What's really going on, of course, is the insertion of fundamentalist religion into government affairs. These folks will tell you, ad nauseum, that they "love the sinner but hate the sin." But "sin" is a religious concept which has no place in secular legislation. And there's a very good reason for that: One man's sin is another man's joy. You might think it's a sin to dance. I don't. Why should your sin be my law? If you want a religious state, move to a country where sin and law are interchangeable. Saudi Arabia comes to mind.
Protecting someone from being fired because they are gay is a simple extension of workers' rights. Your interpretation of the Bible is immaterial.
Here's what really puzzles me: Is it possible that Bunker and these ministers don't know any gay people? I can't imagine that's the case, but equally difficult to imagine is how, if they knew real, actual gay people, they would see this proposed law as a threat. Most of the people I know work with, socialize with, are related to, and interact with gay people on a daily basis. Protecting them from being fired for their orientation seems inherently sensible.
Ironically, the actions of Bunker and his fundamentalist supporters make it obvious why such a law is necessary in the first place.
Oh would some power the giftie gie us, to see ourselves as others see us. — Robert Burns
Scottish poet Robert Burns wrote the line above in response to seeing a louse on a high-born lady's bonnet at church. The point being, of course, that while we might think we're looking pretty good, someone else might be noticing a flaw we've overlooked.
(such a sky and such a sun
i never knew and neither did you
and everybody never breathed
quite so many kinds of yes) — e. e. cummings