Letter from the Editor 

On May 12th, former Mayor Willie Herenton withdrew from a debate with Congressman Steve Cohen that had been scheduled for last week on WREG Channel 13. Herenton said he withdrew because he didn't think two of the debate panelists — WREG's Norm Brewer and The Commercial Appeal's Otis Sanford — would be "fair" with him.

Cohen declined another debate, despite Herenton's apparent efforts to goad him into it. On the Flyer's website this week, Jackson Baker reported on an agreement that Herenton had signed with WMC Channel 5. Herenton's terms included demands that both candidates would stand for the entire debate and that anchor Joe Birch could not ask questions. Presumably, Birch's forthright interview with Herenton last summer led the former mayor to decide that Birch wouldn't be "fair" with him, as well.

I am of two minds about this. On one hand, I think it's entirely plausible that Herenton never wanted a debate in the first place and that all of this talk about a second debate is just gamesmanship designed to make it appear that Herenton is willing to go head-to-head and Cohen is not.

The other scenario is that Herenton wanted to debate but failed to recognize his position, namely that he is the underdog and no longer in a position to make demands of any sort.

Incumbents hold the upper hand in these situations. And those with a substantial lead in the polls try to avoid debates, because they have nothing to gain by putting their opponents on an equal footing. If the challenger doesn't have much money, the prospect of giving an opponent free air-time is even less appealing to an incumbent.

For perspective, reverse the roles. Let's say two-term Congressman Willie Herenton is being challenged by upstart Steve Cohen. Let's say further that Cohen backs out of a scheduled debate, saying he can't get "fair" questions from two of the town's premier journalists. Then he starts demanding that Herenton give him a second debate but insists that both candidates be seated and that yet another prominent local journalist be banned as a potential panelist.

Does anyone really think Congressman Herenton would agree to humor his impudent challenger? If so, I have some Banneker Estates property to sell you. If Herenton actually wanted a debate, he was incredibly naive about the nature of realpolitik. If he didn't want a debate, well, he got his wish.

Bruce VanWyngarden

brucev@memphisflyer.com

Comments (12)

Showing 1-12 of 12

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-12 of 12

Add a comment

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
    • Letter from the Editor

      One of the primary debating points that emerged during the 2012 presidential campaign was that of "takers versus makers." GOP candidate Mitt Romney hammered the point repeatedly to the electorate — that most of those who were backing President Obama in his reelection were takers, living off the efforts of the makers: the noble, hard-working Americans seeking only the freedom to earn a living and provide jobs for all ...

    • Letter From the Editor

      "My monthly prescription is now $15, instead of $150, thanks to the disaster of Obamacare."

      A friend posted the above on her Facebook page this week. The responses to her post were similar. "I had a prescription drop from $300 to $20 a month," wrote one friend. "I got it, too. It'll give me some breathing room," wrote another ...

    • Letter from the Editor

      By the time you read this, authorities may have solved the biggest mystery of the year: What happened to Malaysia Airlines Flight 370? But I doubt it. Even if wreckage is found, it will take a long time — if ever — to figure out who or what caused the jet to diverge from its assigned flight path and disappear from radar. And why ...

More by Bruce VanWyngarden

  • Grizzlies Beat Phoenix, Clinch Post-Season

    • Apr 15, 2014
  • Letter From the Editor

    "My monthly prescription is now $15, instead of $150, thanks to the disaster of Obamacare."

    A friend posted the above on her Facebook page this week. The responses to her post were similar. "I had a prescription drop from $300 to $20 a month," wrote one friend. "I got it, too. It'll give me some breathing room," wrote another ...

    • Apr 10, 2014
  • More »

Top Viewed Stories

ADVERTISEMENT

Site Search

From the Archives

  • Letter from the Editor

    Other people who looked beautiful and who were probably famous were sitting all around me. There were lots of little dogs. People wore tight V-necked T-shirts and had perfect breasts and good hair. And the women were good-looking, too ...
    • Jun 24, 2010
  • Letter from the Editor

    • Jul 8, 2010
  • More »

Most Commented On

  • Letter from the Editor

    One of the primary debating points that emerged during the 2012 presidential campaign was that of "takers versus makers." GOP candidate Mitt Romney hammered the point repeatedly to the electorate — that most of those who were backing President Obama in his reelection were takers, living off the efforts of the makers: the noble, hard-working Americans seeking only the freedom to earn a living and provide jobs for all ...

    • Apr 3, 2014
  • The T-Shirt That Saved Memphis

    • Apr 8, 2014
  • More »

© 1996-2014

Contemporary Media
460 Tennessee Street, 2nd Floor | Memphis, TN 38103
Visit our other sites: Memphis Magazine | Memphis Parent | Memphis Business Quarterly
Powered by Foundation