Letter From The Editor 

On Nathan B. Forrest and Wendi C. Thomas

click to enlarge img_36271-1024x768.jpg

I enjoy Commercial Appeal writer Wendi C. Thomas' columns. I mostly agree with her, and even when I don't, I appreciate her sass, intelligence, and wit. That said, her January 13th column, titled "Marker for Klan founder Forrest moved by KKK's worst nightmare: A powerful black man," was, as Thomas might say, something of a hot mess.

The column was about the removal of a sign put up by the Sons of Confederate Veterans in Forrest Park, which was detailed in last week's Flyer cover story by Jackson Baker. The basic facts are these: Lee Millar, writing as chairman of the Shelby County Historical Commission, offered to put up a new sign for the park. Cindy Buchanan, then the city's park director, responded in a letter to Millar: "The proposal to create a low, monument-style sign of Tennessee granite with the park name carved in the front was reviewed by park design staff and found to be appropriate in concept ... similar to the monument-style signage placed by the city at Overton Park."

George Little, the city CAO, and Mike Flowers, the administrator of park planning and development, were copied on Buchanan's letter.

Millar, who is also an officer of the local chapter of the Sons of Confederate Veterans, got the SCV to come up with the funds for the sign, and it was put up last spring. In October, county commissioner Walter Bailey sent Little a three-part file on the sign and asked that it be taken down.

In December, Baker asked Buchanan about the sign. She said she recalled being asked about the sign but that she "honestly [didn't] remember what I said to them about that." Uh huh. Little told Baker he could find no records of anyone having signed off on the new sign. Millar had no such problem finding the letter from Buchanan that was copied to Little, and he sent a copy to Baker.

In the week between Christmas and New Year's, Little had the sign removed. There is no doubt in my mind that Millar pulled a fast one in using his chairmanship of the Shelby County Historical Society as cover to get a sign erected by the SCV. But he did get city approval.

Thomas portrayed the whole affair as racial, with Little playing the role of a "strong black man" frustrating the Ku Klux Klan. But it seems to me that the removal of the sign was more likely a case of butt-covering by city officials. Demagoguing the affair as "black versus white" does no one any good.

Bruce VanWyngarden

brucev@memphisflyer.com

Comments (61)

Showing 1-25 of 61

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-25 of 61

Comments are closed.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
    • Parks and Rec

      In Overton Park last Sunday, a bunch of people took off their shirts and covered their nipples with various kinds of sticky items in celebration of International Go Topless Day. It was a symbolic protest, claimed organizers, a bold stance against the cruel laws that allow men to take off their shirts in public, but not women ...

    • Two Trains Running

      There's two, two trains running,

      Well, they ain't never going my way.

      One runs at midnight and the other one

      Running just 'fore day. — Muddy Waters

    • Back to the Drawing Board

      Last Friday, the Tennessee Department of Transportation (TDOT) announced that it would delay its planned closure of the I-55 "Old Bridge" over the Mississippi River for at least a year while it conducted "further studies" on the economic impact of the project ...

Blogs

&tcetera

Ann Beattieā€™s Nighttime Reading, Southern-Style

Hungry Memphis

Lunch at Pink Diva Cupcakery

Politics Beat Blog

GOP Luminaries Play the Trump Card at Local Banquet

Tiger Blue

Memphis Tiger Trivia (answer)

Hungry Memphis

Mac's Burger's Loaded Egg Rolls

Music Blog

Manateees at Rocket Science Audio

Film/TV/Etc. Blog

Throwback August: Batman Begins

&tcetera

Get Carded: September Is NLCSM

ADVERTISEMENT

More by Bruce VanWyngarden

  • Parks and Rec

    In Overton Park last Sunday, a bunch of people took off their shirts and covered their nipples with various kinds of sticky items in celebration of International Go Topless Day. It was a symbolic protest, claimed organizers, a bold stance against the cruel laws that allow men to take off their shirts in public, but not women ...

    • Aug 27, 2015
  • Two Trains Running

    There's two, two trains running,

    Well, they ain't never going my way.

    One runs at midnight and the other one

    Running just 'fore day. — Muddy Waters

    • Aug 20, 2015
  • More »
ADVERTISEMENT
© 1996-2015

Contemporary Media
460 Tennessee Street, 2nd Floor | Memphis, TN 38103
Visit our other sites: Memphis Magazine | Memphis Parent | Inside Memphis Business
Powered by Foundation