Malpractice 

Dr. Frist and Mr. DeLay perform surgery on the Constitution.

Senator Bill Frist last week watched a videotape of Terri Schiavo made by her parents in 2001. He did this in his capacity as Senate majority leader and as a physician. In both roles, he performed miserably. As a senator, he showed himself to be an unscrupulous opportunist. As a physician, he was guilty of practicing medicine without a brain.

After viewing the tape, Frist felt confident to question the several courts and many doctors who -- apparently handicapped by first-hand examinations -- had erroneously concluded that Schiavo was in a "persistent vegetative state."

"I question it based on a review of the video footage,'' he told the Senate. "She certainly seems to respond to visual stimuli.'' Doubtful. What's more certain is that Frist and his colleagues were responding to political stimuli.

The unreasonableness of the Republican position -- President Bush hurrying back to Washington to sign the bill as soon as it was passed -- flummoxed speaker after speaker. Representative Tom DeLay, the House majority leader, proved you don't need a medical degree to make foolish statements about Schiavo. "It won't take a miracle to help Terri Schiavo," he said, neglecting to cite his source. "It will only take the medical care and therapy that all patients deserve."

Someone -- no one knows who -- committed candor and truth in Washington (a federal offense?) by circulating a memo to Republicans alerting them to the obvious: Schiavo was "a great political issue." Frist, who is almost certainly running for president next time out, took umbrage at that: "I condemn the content of the memo," he umbraged, "and reaffirm that the interest in this case by myself (and others) is to assure that Mrs. Schiavo has another chance at life."

Bravo! But why not insist that whatever state she's in, she keeps getting a chance at life -- forever? After all, a miracle could happen (DeLay) and she recognizes visual stimuli (Frist) and "she can recover substantially if she gets the proper rehabilitation" (Frist again, this time citing another doctor). Almost no one here is a hands-on doctor, but they don't hesitate to play one on TV.

Watching the House debate Sunday night, I wondered why the Democrats -- some of them, anyway -- even bothered debating the bill. Representative Barney Frank (D-Mass.) was eloquent and persuasive, but the GOP had the votes. Congress was intent on intruding into a family matter in which the courts had ruled repeatedly in favor of the husband. The parents felt otherwise, granted, but they had had their day in court.

Those courts, though, did not rule as Congress would have liked, and so by pretty close to fiat -- no hearings, no witnesses, and absolutely no thought -- the matter was moved to the federal courts where, probably, the outcome will be what it was at the state level. A change in jurisdiction is not going to change Schiavo's condition.

Schiavo's husband said she would not want to live the way she does now -- and that she even said so. But she was only 26 when tragedy struck, probably too young to give serious thought to these matters. Besides, what she once wanted is not the point. That person is gone -- or so say the experts and so say the courts who have heard from the experts.

What remains is a legal case that no longer is about Schiavo. Instead, it's about the politics of abortion -- right to life -- and political opportunism. Terri Schiavo lives so that others, notably Frist, can run for higher office. I know that by watching the tape.

Richard Cohen is a member of the Washington Post Writers Group.

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
    • How Tennessee Turned Red

      Less than a decade ago, the Democratic Party still reigned in this state. So what happened to it?
    • Short-changing Justice in Shelby County

      A Criminal Court judge (unopposed in his race) is disturbed about the quality of some judicial candidates and their reasons for running.
    • The USA: Detention Nation

      We need bold, innovative leadership on the humanitarian crisis unfolding in Central America.

More by Richard Cohen

  • Twerk It!

    Miley Cyrus, Steubenville, and teen culture run amok
    • Sep 5, 2013
  • A Reason To Run

    Just being Hillary Clinton isn’t enough.
    • Aug 15, 2013
  • More »

Top Viewed Stories

ADVERTISEMENT

Flyer Flashback

Looking Back at a Time When We Cared About Your Dreams

Read Story

Site Search

From the Archives

  • A Bitter Pill

    Bredesen's purging of the rolls is the wrong Rx for TennCare.
    • Jan 28, 2005
  • Keep the Faith

    The state made a commitment to its lottery scholars; it should stand by it.
    • Feb 4, 2005
  • More »

© 1996-2014

Contemporary Media
460 Tennessee Street, 2nd Floor | Memphis, TN 38103
Visit our other sites: Memphis Magazine | Memphis Parent | Memphis Business Quarterly
Powered by Foundation