POLITICS: Shameless Meddling 

FLYER Editorial :

Shameless Medsdling

Both 4th District congressman Van Hilleary, the presumed Republican front-runner for governor , and ex-Nashville mayor Phil Bredesen, regarded as a prohibitive favorite among the Democrats, have done their best -which is to say, their worst- to prevent the Tennessee legislature from dealing with a state fiscal crisis that is on the edge of disaster.

In the last week or so there have been fresh signs that the legislature might actually hazard a long overdue solution to a revenue shortfall which is heading toward the two-billion-dollar mark. For three years legislators have dithered and ducked their duty as emergency funds were raided and basic state services - notably including education -were cut to the bone. The state House of Representatives made it clear that it would not approve any further increase in the state's already oppressively high sales tax. The Senate contains members who have held the line against an income tax. And special-interest lobbyists have prevented substantial revenue solutions of any other kind.

Finally, it began to appear that both legislative chambers of the General Assembly might agree on a mild, "flat-tax" version of an income tax. Such was the word tentatively passed last week on Capitol Hill in Nashville and reinforced later in the week on the grounds of the Covington Country Club, where throngs of influential politicians gather annually for House Speaker Jimmy Naifeh's "Coon Supper."

But that was before Messrs. Hilleary and Bredesen butted in. In their gubernatorial campaigns so far, both - no doubt influenced by intense and highly organized propaganda campaigns overseen by radio talk-show hosts and others -had taken stands against a state income tax. Both were undoubtedly mindful that a virtual riot whetted up by income-tax opponents brought state government to a panicky standstill last July and forced the emergency use of tobacco-settlement funds merely to provide for minimum levels of state services. Even the use of those one-time funds, however, did not prevent draconian cuts forced upon Governor Don Sundquist in the areas of state parks, education spending, and health-care.

As Sundquist, an advocate of tax reform, said at Covington the other day, he felt vindicated in that even longstanding opponents of revenue adjustment had admitted the urgency of the moment and had begun to come around. Hence, the pending flat-tax vote.

Enter Hilleary and Bredesen, each of whom released statements this week that he would seek to "repeal" a state flat tax if one were to be passed by the General Assembly this year. Nothing could have been better calculated to undercut the last-ditch efforts of the governor and legislative leaders to avert the gathering financial catastrophe.

Hilleary, at least, can point to a substantial number of his partymates who are adamantly opposed to a state income tax. Bredesen can boast of no such groundswell among state Democrats. Both men come off as unacceptably opportunistic. Whatever their personal convictions, each could have - and should have -declined to interfere with the legislative process under way.

We do not endorse in election races, but we would be remiss not to point out that Republican gubernatorial candidate Jim Henry, while opposing an income tax, too, has been open-minded enough not to rule it out. Democrat Randy Nichols has been sufficienctly brave to campaign in favor of an income tax, while another Democrat, Charles Smith, has accused Bredesen and Hilleary of "pandering" and has promised to make no comments of his own on the legislature's ongoing deliberations.

Illustrations, if you will, of the difference between statesmanship and demagoguery. (Care to respond? Write mailonthefly@aol.com.)


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment


More by Jackson Baker

  • “Open Carry” Gun Bill Killed

    With a convincing 10-1 vote against it, the state House Finance subcommittee rejects legislation previously passed by the Senate but opposed by the Haslam administration..
    • Apr 15, 2014
  • Nice Guys Finish Tied

    There was no clear winner in the tentative, good-willed first matchup between rival Democratic candidates for Shelby County Mayor.
    • Apr 13, 2014
  • More »

Top Viewed Stories


Site Search

From the Archives


    Why Memphis is the perfect city for the Tyson/Lewis fight
    • Mar 15, 2002

    Judge sets new hearing for adult-novelty store.
    • Mar 17, 2002
  • More »

Most Commented On

© 1996-2014

Contemporary Media
460 Tennessee Street, 2nd Floor | Memphis, TN 38103
Visit our other sites: Memphis Magazine | Memphis Parent | Memphis Business Quarterly
Powered by Foundation