There are two kinds of people in this world: those who hear “fish sauce in a cocktail” and think hmm, interesting, and those who immediately start looking for the nearest exit.
Tony Nguyen, beverage and service director at Crosstown Vietnamese restaurant Bao Toan, has served both.
Fish sauce appeared on the original cocktail menu, but has since retired. Nguyen hasn’t exactly gone mainstream, though. The new menu, launched last month, features surprises from beet juice and artichoke amaro to banana “caviar,” housemade fruit rollups, and Vietnamese coffee juiced up with Hennessy.
Nguyen isn’t creating unusual cocktails simply because he can. He’s fascinated by what happens when Vietnamese ingredients and techniques get into a cocktail shaker and start misbehaving. “Fish sauce may turn some people off,” he says. On the old menu, he used a dash to add a salty, savory note, or “just enough to alter the molecular composition of the cocktail.”

Sometimes the combinations are intuitive: ginger, carrot and lemon. Cucumber, yuzu, and mint. And sometimes they take a sharp left turn. Take the Imperial Citadel, Nguyen’s favorite drink on the new menu. It began with tequila and oysters topped with caviar and eventually emerged as a clarified, smoky mezcal cocktail served over a giant rock and topped with banana “caviar.”
The caviar, needless to say, is not caviar. It’s somewhere between caviar and boba, with tiny pearls that pop with little bursts of banana flavor. Excellent costume design, remarkable texture.
Nguyen says his process is essentially an elaborate series of Hey, I wonder what this would taste like? His most successful experiments make the menu.
The City of Eternal Springs, a gorgeous fuchsia gin cocktail tempered with beet juice, might give a cautious drinker pause, at least until the first sip. We both loved it. The Historical Influence is sneakier: Nguyen’s interpretation of an espresso martini, with a nod to the French influence on Vietnamese cuisine.
Then there’s Island Life, a take on the Mai Tai. It starts out like a mouthful of the tropics, with Blue Note rye, overproof rum and Campari, and then the German digestif Underberg shakes things up. Nguyen calls it a bitter Mai Tai; we call it a drink that knows exactly how innocent it looks.
You don’t have to know what banana caviar is. You don’t have to understand why somebody put artichoke amaro in your drink. And you definitely don’t have to be the person who hears “fish sauce” and says, “Sign me up.” You just have to be willing to explore.
Our Bao Toan Cocktail Cheat Sheet
• The One That Makes Us Feel Smart:Imperial Citadel. Mezcal, Salers, Lillet Blanc, and banana caviar? Obviously we know what we’re doing. (Hint: sample the caviar, then take a sip.)
•The One We’ll Order Again: City of Eternal Springs. We both default to gin-based cocktails. However, beet juice is not generally how we begin an evening. And yet.
• The One We’re Afraid Of: Coconut Capital, Nguyen’s nod to the Mekong Delta, with tequila, coconut, caffeine-free butterfly pea tea, and orange blossom. It could easily get us into trouble. We also have concerns about Floating Markets, a rum-and-Faccia Brutto combination that goes down a little too easy.
• The One That Tastes Like Vacation:Nguyen describes Island Life as a journey. We describe it as a Mai Tai that has seen some things, like Sam Rockwell’s character in The White Lotus.
• The One You Can’t Miss:Last May, Nguyen created a pairing dinner billed as “Four courses, four cocktails, zero regrets.” We were happy to be guinea pigs. He plans more of these events for the future. Consider it your excuse to let him do the thinking for you.
Pro Tip: Not indulging in dinner? Do happy hour. Sit at the bar, chat with your bartender, and get a snack like the khai vị ba món with your cocktail. The platter of pork, shrimp, and beef rolls will help soak up all that booze.

