Among School Children 

The surprising emotional truths of High School Musical 3.

The Disney Channel's High School Musical series has never been as generic or as bland as its name implies. Sure, all three installments of this wildly successful franchise are set in an ultra-hygienic, sun-kissed learning funplex where classes last five minutes, pep fests draw thousands of enthusiastic students, the drama kids get the best seats in the cafeteria, and everyone is pretty, reasonably well-adjusted, and likely to burst into song at any moment. But let's face it: No matter what you thought of your own high school experience, High School Musical's idyllic fantasyland is a much more pleasant place than the grubby, cynical, supposedly authentic teenage world of Superbad or Sex Drive.

Besides, attention should be paid to any series clever enough to name a character after the evil Puritan magistrate in Arthur Miller's play The Crucible (the uninspired reading and discussion of which is a widespread high school ritual all its own) and structure its catchiest musical number around the dangers of defying an artificial social order. But I was more than a little stunned by the conceptual and artistic merits of High School Musical 3: Senior Year, which — impossibly, gloriously — contains some of the year's most exciting and emotionally resonant sequences.

HSM 3 begins in chaos. Troy Bolton (Zac Efron), point guard of the softest, most well-choreographed basketball team in New Mexico history, is in trouble: His East High team is getting destroyed by West High in the championship game. Meanwhile, the other pressures of senior year loom for Troy and his pals on and off the court: graduation, college, separation from the womb of public education, and, of course, the successful production of cell-phone-obsessed drama teacher Mrs. Darbus' spring musical.

Mrs. Darbus (Alyson Reed) ameliorates this teenage uncertainty through art therapy: She instructs her gifted teen composer (Olesya Rulin, a butch Radar O'Reilly) and choreographer (Lucas Grabeel, impeccably sweatered and not-so-secretly trapped in the closet) to write and stage a meta-play about the student body's hopes, dreams, and fears. As a result, the numerous musical numbers drift between fantasy and reality, evoking a state of dream-like delirium.

The film's handling of teenage love and lust is absurdly chaste but nonetheless refreshing. Only super-pimps would feed their lady chocolate-covered strawberries, but only High School Musical's stars would finish this meal with discreet kisses on the cheek. Instead of focusing on the free-floating sexual hunger endemic to more "adult" teenage fare, though, the film explores deeper and pricklier questions about adolescent identity.

This emphasis on the twin pressures of parental expectations and individual soul-searching adds necessary weight to the thin storyline. And these internal conflicts are clarified by the much-improved cinematography. I hated the over-bright TV-movie look of the previous films; every shadowless face and body seemed lit by several maximum-security prison-yard spotlights. The visuals in HSM 3 are more nuanced while embracing a vibrant color palate of pinks, reds, lavenders, and whites.

The two revelatory numbers involve the two marquee stars, Troy and his stalwart sweetheart Gabriella (Vanessa Anne Hudgens). Hudgens' musical number limns the emotional sorrow of a peripatetic teen; she sings her goodbyes to her man and her community as the pictures on the walls vanish behind her. Efron's solo epiphany occurs as he survives a hailstorm of basketballs in the gym and stalks the halls in search of his true self. These two scenes, as well as the bittersweet, schizophrenic showstopper, are riveting tweener psychodrama precisely because they are so unexpected. For a few minutes, anyway, these wooden idols become real boys and girls.

High School Musical 3: Senior Year

Now playing

Multiple locations

Keep the Flyer Free!

Always independent, always free (never a paywall),
the Memphis Flyer is your source for the best in local news and information.

Now we want to expand and enhance our work.
That's why we're asking you to join us as a Frequent Flyer member.

You'll get membership perks (find out more about those here) and help us continue to deliver the independent journalism you've come to expect.



Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Speaking of High School Musical 3, movie Reviews

Rated PG · 96 min. · 2008
Official Site:
Director: Chris Williams and Byron Howard
Writer: Chris Sanders
Producer: Clark Spencer
Cast: John Travolta, Miley Cyrus, Susie Essman, Mark Walton, Malcolm McDowell, Diedrich Bader, Nick Swardson, Chloe Moretz, Greg Germann and Ronn Moss
High School Musical 3: Senior Year
Rated G · 100 min. · 2008
Official Site:
Director: Kenny Ortega
Writer: Peter Barsocchini
Producer: Bill Borden
Cast: Zac Efron, Vanessa Anne Hudgens, Ashley Tisdale, Corbin Bleu, Monique Coleman, Olesya Rulin, Chris Warren Jr., Ryne Sanborn, Kaycee Stroh and Bart Johnson


Now Playing

Bolt, and High School Musical 3: Senior Year are not showing in any theaters in the area.

What others are saying


    The Latest

    Film/TV/Etc. Blog

    The Return of the King: Eddie Murphy Rules in Coming 2 America

    Film/TV/Etc. Blog

    Zamundan Flag Flies for Craig Brewer's Coming 2 America Premiere

    News Blog

    New COVID-19 Virus Cases Up by 178

    Sports Feature

    Memphis 901 FC Signs Goalkeeper John Berner

    TV Features

    The MCU Assumes its Final Form with WandaVision

    Hungry Memphis

    La Baguette French Bread and Pastry Shop is Sold

    News Blog

    New Virus Cases Rise By 129


    More by Addison Engelking

    Readers also liked…

    © 1996-2021

    Contemporary Media
    65 Union, 2nd Floor | Memphis, TN 38103
    Visit our other sites: Memphis Magazine | Memphis Parent | Inside Memphis Business
    Powered by Foundation