An Exaggerated Take on Sisterhood 

Lisa See has done it again. And depending on your taste for the sentimental, this could be delightful or torturous.

Snowflower and the Secret Fan — adapted from See's novel — is the story of four women: Snowflower (Gianna Jun) and Lily (Bingbing Li) live in 19th-century China; Sophia and Nina (also played by Jun and Li) live in present-day Shanghai.

Director Wayne Wang (The Joy Luck Club) wastes no time getting into the thick of the melodrama. Sophia falls into a coma after a nasty cycling accident and the tragedy brings her recent falling-out with lifelong friend Nina to the fore. From there, we are led through the development of Nina and Sophia's relationship, braided with the similarly fraught story of Snowflower and Lily.

The double casting of Jun and Li links the stories from past and present. "It's about the old days," says Sophia about the Snowflower and Lily saga, "but I think it's really about us." After simultaneous foot binding ceremonies, Snowflower and Lily are matched up as laotong, symbolic sisters united for eternity. In perfect symmetry, Nina and Sophia are also determined to be laotong and share this sacred bond, which even comes with its own secret language, nushu or "women's script." Snowflower and Lily pass news of their tumultuous lives, written between the folds of a traditional Chinese fan.

Both laotong pairs experience a range of joys and sorrows together. Marriage, pregnancy, death, and divorce are set against the backdrop of their undying affection, butting up against one another with the cumulative effect of a Lifetime movie. Foot binding, ever-present throughout the film, is never engaged in a meaningful way. Instead, it's hung out as a grim ornament lending more empty drama to the story.

The bond of laotong is also strangely off-putting. It comes across as an overly possessive friendship. It transcends marriage. Biological sisterhood has the gravitas of pen pals by comparison.

But it also works perfectly within the schema of See's mawkish pseudo-feminist best-sellers. Without much of interest or substance to back up these lifelong friendships, the women are more in love with the idea of sisterhood than anything else. Their laotong bond becomes an exercise in developing hyper-significant relationships. Predictably, their friendship only falters for all-too-perfect reasons — when one of the women selflessly lets go as she feels she is too much of a burden on her sister.

The film is nicely shot, with two cleanly interwoven storylines, and is by no means difficult to look at. And while See's romanticized indulgence in the ultra-feminine is tiresome, her track record of best-sellers is impressive.

Snowflower was manufactured to jerk the tears out of you, and, evidently, enough people are looking for a good reason to cry these days. If you like doing your crying in the dark and you aren't too picky about the plot, I've got a movie ticket to sell you.

Snow Flower and the Secret Fan
Opening Friday, August 5th
Ridgeway Four

Related Locations

Keep the Flyer Free!

Always independent, always free (never a paywall),
the Memphis Flyer is your source for the best in local news and information.

Now we want to expand and enhance our work.
That's why we're asking you to join us as a Frequent Flyer member.

You'll get membership perks (find out more about those here) and help us continue to deliver the independent journalism you've come to expect.



Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Speaking of Malco Ridgeway Four


The Latest

Tiger Blue

Tulsa 58, Tigers 57

Sports Feature

Memphis 901 FC Transfer Tracker - Pierre da Silva Off to Miami

Memphis Gaydar

OUTMemphis Celebrates Pandemic Wins

Beyond the Arc

Can the Grizzlies Keep the Streak Alive in Minnesota?

News Blog

Council Renaming Commission Discusses Requirements

News Blog

Temporary Downtown Gallery Features Regional Artists

Film Features

The Greatest: Four Legends Gather in One Night in Miami

News Blog

Tennessee Tops U-Haul's List for Movers


More by Hannah Sayle

  • Recipe for Success

    Andrew Ticer and Michael Hudman on their new cookbook, Collards & Carbonara.
    • Aug 29, 2013
  • Open House

    The historic Magevney House will soon reopen to the public.
    • Aug 22, 2013
  • Spectacular, Now

    An unusually superb teen romance.
    • Aug 22, 2013
  • More »

Readers also liked…

© 1996-2021

Contemporary Media
65 Union, 2nd Floor | Memphis, TN 38103
Visit our other sites: Memphis Magazine | Memphis Parent | Inside Memphis Business
Powered by Foundation