GADFLY: Uncivil War in Iraq 

Civil war? What civil war?

            In a page taken from the Clinton "it depends on what the meaning of 'is' is," the powers that be in the Bush Administration are bending over backwards to deny that the sectarian violence which has been racking Iraq for months, suddenly ratcheting up in recent weeks with the bombing of a mosque in Samarra, and hundreds of Iraqis turning up dead in execution-style killings, constitutes a civil war. Dick Cheney Donald Rumsfeld and his military minions have all denied the existence of a civil war. Remember what they say about not believing something until it's officially denied?

            However, most of the people either "on the ground," or with their ears to it, seem to disagree. Ayad Allawi, the U.S.'s hand-picked interim prime minister of Iraq, has been quoted as saying the country is in the midst of a civil war. The New York Times' bureau chief in Baghdad, John Burns, has said the country has been in a civil war for some time,. The prominent (and militarily well-connected) Democrat, John Murtha, has said the same thing as has at least one outspoken Republican war veteran, Chuck Hagel, the Republican senator from Nebraska, who said the following:

The former prime minister [Allawi] is correct. I think we have had a low-grade civil war going on in Iraq, certainly the last six months, maybe the last year. Our own generals have told me that privately. So that's a fact.

            I agree that there is not a civil war in Iraq, since there is nothing civil about the conflict between the Shi'ite and Sunnis that is killing, according to Allawi, 50 to 60 people every day, and well over 1,000 so far. All this denial and avoidance by the administration made me think the only thing Rummy and Co. would recognize as a civil war in Iraq was if the factions came out one day dressed in the costumes so popular with re-enactors of the American civil war, the Sunnis in Blue and the Shiites in Grey.

            But then Rumsfeld appeared to debunk that notion when he said (about a civil war in Iraq), "I don't think it'll look like the United States' civil war.". His statement, hedging as it did about his uncertainty that the combatants in an Iraqi civil war might look like the ones at Gettysburg or Shiloh, reinforces my belief that's exactly what it will take for the likes of Rummy to admit the existence of a civil war in Iraq.

            No one questions that the conflicts involving the Serbs and Croats in Bosnia, the Hutus and Tutsis in Rwanda, the Christians and Muslims in Lebanon, or for that matter, the war between the North and South Vietnamese, were all civil wars. They all had common elements, whether conflicting political ideologies, ethnicity, religious beliefs, or claims to territory or governance, which are also present in the Iraqi civil war, and they all involved the killings of and by fellow countrymen. The other common element? To one degree or another, most foreign civil wars have been either the cause or effect of American meddling.

            So what's the problem with admitting Iraq has fallen into a state of civil war? Well, it's the same reason the administration has difficulty admitting that the presence of American troops not only has failed to stem the tide of terror, but has actually increased and served as a spawning ground for it. If our war president and his stooges can successfully deny the existence of a civil war, he can avoid taking any responsibility for it (an evasion he has raised to a high art). But more importantly, once it is generally accepted that Iraq has degenerated into a state of civil war, any remaining rationale for a continued American presence evaporates, as does what little public support remains for that intervention. It's one thing to build a nation; it's quite another to have to dodge IED's, RPG's and bullets just to preside over its self destruction.

Want to respond? Send us an email here.



Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment



We Saw You

Military Masquerade, Maciel's Highland, The Gray Canary

Hungry Memphis

Beer Bracket Challenge, Round 2


Tayari Jones Reading at the Orpheum

Hungry Memphis

Muddy's Bake Shop Turns 10

Tiger Blue

Tigers 91, #23 Houston 85

Intermission Impossible

Dead in the Water: New Moon's "Eurydice" is wet and wonderful

Politics Beat Blog

Alexander Touts Tax Bill, Offers Proposals on Guns and Immigration

News Blog

Memphis Pets of the Week


More by Marty Aussenberg

  • Union Made

    At this low point in labor history, the Gadfly is on strike from the consensus.
    • Jun 28, 2012
  • GADFLY: It's Fall Already, but "Occupy Wall Street" Has Finally Brought an American Spring

    "The media were faced with the problem of how best to discredit this rising tide of protest, and settled on suggesting that the protesters didn't even know what they were protesting about.... Strange how that criticism was never leveled at the Tea Party...."
    • Oct 3, 2011
  • GADFLY: Our 9/11 Mourning is Misdirected

    "I would rather mourn the lack of accountability of the people who let it happen, or the people who continue to be its victims, far-removed from where it happened though they may be...."
    • Sep 13, 2011
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Filling the Space

    For all the in-fighting, we’re all looking for the same thing, and sometimes we can realize it.
    • Jul 14, 2016
  • Wellspring Politics in Memphis

    With a crucial deadline approaching next week, the local “Protect the Aquifier” movement picks up steam.
    • Nov 24, 2016
  • Kelsey, Harris: Bipartisan Effort on Aquifer Issue

    Plus, DNC aspirant Ellison arouses youthful attendees at national Young Democrat conference here.
    • Dec 15, 2016
© 1996-2018

Contemporary Media
460 Tennessee Street, 2nd Floor | Memphis, TN 38103
Visit our other sites: Memphis Magazine | Memphis Parent | Inside Memphis Business
Powered by Foundation