Local environmental group Young, Gifted & Green (YGAG) said Shelby County Commissioner Amber Huett-Garciaโs proposed new data center ordinance still needs work.
A little over a week before the ordinance was to go back before county commissioners, Huett-Garcia answered questions at a November 9th town hall meeting, where she said there were few concerns.
YGAG CEO LaTricea Adams, however, said the ordinance isnโt ready, though it is an improvement compared to the city of Memphisโ proposed data center ordinance. โIt needs more time,โ she said.
On October 21st, Huett-Garcia introduced an ordinance in what her blog says is an effort to get ahead of any future projects and establish rules before any come in. โThis ordinance moves to define what a data center is and โฆ move it to light industrial,โ she said.
Huett-Garcia referred to the specific land-use zoning category under Ordinance No. 397, also known as the Memphis and Shelby County Unified Development Code (UDC). Businesses categorized as โlight industrialโ are intended to have minimal negative impacts on surroundings, being required by the UDC to โbe operated in a relatively clean and quiet manner.โ
Currently, the UDC does not classify data centers as distinct land use, leaving them unrecognized as a separate category. This means developers are allowed to build data centers under general designations, without data-center-specific rules around their water, energy, and noise impacts. โWe kind of treat them like office spaces,โ said Huett-Garcia.
The commissionerโs ordinance would amend this. Huett-Garcia created a section on her blog detailing the ordinance in plain language, explaining why it was created and what it involves. The post explained how enforcement would work. Information on how much water and energy a center uses would be made public, for example, to allow for public reporting. It would also require a yearly sign-off from an engineer, officer, or manager saying the data center is following the rules.
Huett-Garcia said there werenโt many concerns brought to her at the town hall. โWhat individuals were sharing to me was like โฆ itโs a [question] of whether we can hold them accountable,โ referring to data center projects. โNot the language itself.โ
Part of her efforts toward accountability involve โspecial-use permits,โ which allow a property owner to use land under certain conditions. โLetโs say a company comes in and says, โOh, weโre going to build a greywater facility,โ right?โ Huett-Garcia said in her example, referring to data centers.
โWe can say as part of that permit, we want the construction started before you start your build or we will revoke your special-use permit,โ she continued.
In all, Huett-Garcia said her ordinance is very close to being ready.
Adams disagreed, and echoed the concerns about accountability. She said while the proposed ordinance โisnโt terrible,โ there are still many gaps. โ[An] aspect that has not been mentioned at all is about wildlife.โ
The YGAG CEO said she also has concerns around who would be responsible if there was an environmental emergency at a data center. โI have seen, while serving on the Biden-Harris administration, some of these developments that are highly polluting,โ she said. โParticularly new ones with not a lot of research, weโve seen catastrophe.โ
Currently, the proposed ordinance does not address these concerns.
Adams detailed other protections that are absent from the ordinance which she would like to see, including a requirement for soil samples and a ban on PFAS chemicals, also known as โforever chemicals.โ
Adams welcomed the idea of both a moratorium and an ordinance. โThe moratorium serves as a bridge, to make sure that you are trying to establish the most common sense, the most rigorous protective standards,โ she said.
Huett-Garcia said the countyโs hands are tied regarding what rules they are and are not allowed to make, due to their limited authority. โA good example is forever chemicals,โ she said. โWe do not have the ability as the county to ban them. That is a state-level decision, and Tennessee has not [banned them].โ
The commissioner also addressed the lack of wildlife and wetlands specifications. โWildlife and habitat are also governed by state and federal law, including the Endangered Species Act and state permits for disturbing streams and wetlands,โ Huett-Garcia said.
On Wednesday, November 18th, the Shelby County Board of Commissioners will revisit Huett-Garciaโs proposed ordinance. The meeting will not constitute a final vote on the ordinance, as it must be presented three times in total before it can pass.

