Tuesday, August 24, 2010

Michael Heisley, Annotated -- Part One

Posted by Chris Herrington on Tue, Aug 24, 2010 at 12:55 PM

Grizzlies owner Michael Heisley appeared on The Chris Vernon Show yesterday afternoon and submitted to a 37-minute interview. It was noisy and combative in part because Vernon, always animated, asked tough questions and backed them up with a solid understanding of the way the NBA works, a combination Heisley rarely confronts in his local media appearances. The tenor of the interview was also a result of Heisley's seeming inability to control his tone when challenged.

memphis-grizzlies-owner-michael-heisley.jpg
It seems like Heisley thinks his bluster is charming — or maybe he just doesn't think about it at all — but as he's pushed himself further and further into the spotlight as the team's chief spokesperson and acknowledged decision-maker, his manner has instead become increasingly tiresome and counterproductive. Needless to say, this was a borderline-embarrassing performance for the owner of the city's only professional sports franchise. This doesn't all come through on a transcript, and I'm going to focus here primarily on the content of some of the things Heisley said, but I encourage anyone who hasn't done so to listen to the interview. You can do so here or also on iTunes, where the show is now available for download. The audio reveals much more than mere words can suggest.

Rather than go through the entire interview — and really, there's enough there to warrant that — I'm going to jump around and pull out a few exchanges and assertions that demand commentary. Even being selective, this is too long for one post, so I'm breaking it into two posts.

On the Xavier Henry contract situation, which takes up a large portion of the interview:

Heisley: The facts are that in the collective bargaining agreement for draft contracts, there is 40% available [for negotiation]. So we put in some performance criteria and the agent for Xavier, Arn Tellem, he thinks that's not right and not fair and he's advised his client not to sign.

Vernon: And you admit this is not the way business is usually conducted with rookies and their contracts and this is why Xavier Henry and Greivis Vasquez are the only two rookies still unsigned? You understand that you're the ones doing this and you're fine with that?

Heisley: What do you mean? We're the ones doing what?

Vernon: You are adding the performance bonus. It is typically customary to give the player the 120% of their rookie scale, and, in fact, that is what you've done in the past.

Heisley: I'll be very honest with you, I have not handled this in the past. And, quite honestly, I wasn't even aware that was in the collective bargaining agreement until this year.

I'm not going to get into the particulars of the Henry negotiation, because I did that here. Suffice it to say that Heisley makes a perfectly reasonable case that real performance incentives should be the norm for rookie contracts, but his lack of knowledge or concern about league-wide practices and the meaning of going against them is problematic. These issues will come up again.

For now, what's most striking is Heisley's admission that he wasn't aware of the negotiating room built into rookie contracts until this summer. Now, here and throughout our look at this interview, we have to establish that we shouldn't judge Heisley by the normal standards of an NBA owner. Since the departure of Jerry West, Heisley, by his own admission, has taken a more active role in team management. Behind the scenes and as a public voice, he has become the team's de facto president of basketball operations and thus has to be judged by a different standard than owners who allow their executives to operate with more autonomy and less interference.

Though he denies it on a follow-up question, Heisley gives the strong impression of being out of sorts about past rookie performance, which may have led to him taking a more personal interest in negotiations this time. This is one potential answer to the question of why the Grizzlies changed their stance toward rookie contracts this season. But the other comes here:


Vernon: Did this way of conducting business regarding the rookie contracts just come to you after reading the collective bargaining agreement? It appears as if you had this epiphany after reading the collective bargaining agreement — 'Oh my god, why are we conducting our business this way. Here I am reading the collective bargaining agreement and we don't have to do it this way.'

Heisley: I've never seen the collective bargaining agreement.

Vernon: What?

Heisley: I've never seen it.

Vernon: How is that possible?

Heisley: It's very possible. Are there things you haven't seen in your life?

Vernon: Well, I don't own an NBA franchise.

Heisley: What would you do, study the collective bargaining agreement?

Vernon: Absolutely.

This is where a lot of Grizzlies fans had to start getting very depressed. Apparently, Heisley hasn't demanded stronger performance clauses in the past because he didn't know that he could.

Heisley pushes against Vernon's own knowledge of the CBA here, as if Vernon should be held to the same standard and unaware that his interviewer does actually have decent grasp of league rules. He makes a case for the advisory role of his staff that essentially makes Heisley sound like Jerry West and Chris Wallace sound like Tom Penn (West's assistant general manger during his Memphis tenure).

Intimate knowledge of the collective bargaining agreement may not be a prerequisite for NBA owners, since, typically, general managers and other executives are charged with that. But the problem here, again, is that Heisley has appointed himself the de facto president of basketball ops. Owners always have the final say on major decisions, but this has become something a little different from that norm. And if Heisley is going to be directly driving much of the day-to-day operation of the team (down to something as ostensibly minor as negotiating rookie contracts) then it is not okay that he knows less about the contents of the CBA — essentially the league's team-building rule book — than I do. Have I read the CBA? No. But I've read pretty much all of Larry Coon's essential CBA FAQ. Many who cover the NBA and even many fans of the sport appear to have a broader working knowledge of the league's rules than the primary decision maker of the Memphis Grizzlies. Make you feel good, Grizzlies fans?

Heisley: [Chris Wallace] is the expert on the collective bargaining agreement. If you want to discuss the collective bargaining agreement, you should put Chris on the air.

Vernon: Well, in so many cases, you have made it abundantly clear that Chris Wallace [isn't] making the decisions.

Vernon puts Wallace on the air every week, of course, and they dance around these issues every week, sometimes in painfully awkward ways. Heisley doesn't seem to realize what he's done to his own general manager. Why would you want to bring Wallace on to talk about this when Heisley has made it clear that Wallace has little to do with the decision in question? And when, in fact, it is often understood that Wallace sometimes doesn't fully agree with Heisley-dictated decisions (see: Iverson, Allen, and Warrick, Hakim) and is instead playing the good soldier.

At this point, Heisley goes back to discussing the CBA language governing rookie-scale salaries, which he apparently just discovered this season. Heisley basically says that that provisions were pointed out to him this summer by an employee and he didn't understand why the team hadn't been insisting on stronger performance clauses all along, so he decided to ask for them now. I wonder if the person who drew Heisley's attention to this clause now regrets it?

Vernon: You have 29 other teams conducting themselves one way and then you …

Heisley (nearly yelling): That is not true!

Vernon: What do you mean it's not true?

Heisley: It's not true. What don't you understand about not true?

Vernon: Well, you're the only team that hasn't signed their rookies?

Heisley: What?

Vernon: You're the only team that hasn't signed its rookies.

Heisley: That may or may not be true either.

Vernon: No, that is true.

Heisley: Wait a minute, I don't know that. But the first statement was not true.

There are two issues here. Heisley's correction that the Grizzlies aren't the only team to ask for performance bonuses in rookie contracts this season is apparently correct. (The Spurs appear to have used some form of performance bonus for first-round pick James Anderson, whom they've managed to sign.)

But it's distressing that, despite personally demanding the inclusion of the performance bonuses and despite giving several interviews on the subject, Heisley seems less aware of the status of the team's negotiations relative to the rest of the league than most fans. Yes, Mr. Heisley, it is true the Henry and Vasquez are the only domestic first-round picks still unsigned.

I will tell you point blank son, the press doesn't influence me one iota.

One of my favorite one-liners of the interview. If you listen to the whole thing, you'll find that, on this issue, Heisley seems to protest too much, given how often he brings up the media.

In part two, we'll get into Heisley's comments on his fitness to call the shots, his team's relative success, the Thabeet/Rubio question, the departure of Hakim Warrick, and more.

Comments (13)

Showing 1-13 of 13

Add a comment

it was an absolute train wreck. couldn't believe what i was hearing.
spot on analysis. dont see how i'll be able to renew tickets after this season. i would cancel now but i've already paid for them and with the lock out coming i want to see ball while i can.
that said, id rather the grizzlies leave memphis if they continue under Heisleys reign. too unreal for words. absolute depression is setting in.

report   
Posted by sparksmemphis on August 24, 2010 at 1:37 PM

Embarrassing. If we can't get a local owner, let Heisley buy us out and move the team to Seattle or Vegas. He may be a successful businessman, but he just doesn't get how an NBA team should be a positive endeavor for its host city, not a means of humiliation.

Oh, and that "son" comment, just dripped with condescension. Good job by Verno.

report   
Posted by formanner on August 24, 2010 at 1:58 PM

I hated that interview so so much for so many reasons. How in the world did this guy get this out of touch with Memphis or the NBA? There were so many parts to the interview (the very beginning when he dropped about 76 umms or uhhhs...YOU ARE ON THE RADIO!!! YOU KNEW YOU WOULD BE ON THE RADIO!!!! PREPARE TO SPEAK ENGLISH!!!) that made me either uncomfortable/angry/depressed/embarrassed. I think that last one just about sums it up...embarrassed. I am embarrassed that he is the owner, that he is running the show, and that he is dragging Memphis down in the mud. I would rather go see the Redbirds play these days than support the Grizzlies...and I LOVE THE GRIZZLIES!! I just hate Heisley. Can the city of Memphis buy the team like Green Bay did with the Packers? Or at least pick up the tab on whatever the local ownership group can't afford?

I mean, what else can you say when your owner/GM/czar of the team sounds like an old man returning soup at a deli?

report   
Posted by coolbreeze on August 24, 2010 at 2:14 PM

The gloom and despair that I feel ..............
Give me a break. Whiners. Someone start passing out tissue.



report   
Posted by 38103 on August 24, 2010 at 3:01 PM

Heisley uh has uh some uh control uh and uh anger uh issues uh

report   
Posted by grizzfan79 on August 24, 2010 at 4:18 PM

If that is how he runs meetings it is no wonder we wound up with Thabeet and Carrol.

report   
Posted by Evil on August 24, 2010 at 7:10 PM

I agree with 38103 about this: As critical as I am about how Heisley conducts himself as owner, I don't think it's reason to not be interested in the team. There are plenty of good and talented people in that organization, on the floor and off, and they've put together an entertaining and competitive team after three years of floundering. If you live in the Memphis area and like basketball, you should be very interested in following that team, regardless of the obstacles Heisley has at times put in the way.

report   
Posted by Chris Herrington on August 24, 2010 at 7:19 PM

In spite of Michael Heisley the Grizzlies had the 2nd biggest improvement in wins in the entire league last year going from 24 wins to 40 wins. In spite of MH, somebody's doing something right. Remember Heisley is 74 years old now. Just because of his age, I can see him getting out very soon. The contracts in place will keep this team here long after he's out. Most people really don't think about the owner, they just go to see some good hoops. After all, last years team won more and average attendance and tv ratings both increased. If you were to take a survey of people coming to the games and asked who the owner is, the vast majority couldn't tell you.

report   
Posted by Midtown Mark on August 24, 2010 at 8:16 PM

Coolbreeze: Regarding your thought on Memphians buying the Grizzlies a la the Packers, I wrote about that (plug alert) in the Spring 2010 MBQ: Page 6 at http://www.mbqmemphis.com/mbq-spring-2010.

But, I've since learned that a Packers-style ownership structure is not allowed under NBA rules.

Too bad, so sad.

report   
Posted by Greg Akers on August 24, 2010 at 8:53 PM

Hey, where's the Jerry Schilling/Memphis Beat finale live blog happening?

report   
Posted by BruceVanWyngarden on August 24, 2010 at 9:10 PM

I've got the Memphis Beat beat this week. Watching on DVR delay later tonight. No spoilers!

report   
Posted by Chris Herrington on August 24, 2010 at 9:29 PM

Yeah. I had read about the Packers ownership being "grandfathered in" with the NFL so I assumed there were rules in place now to keep that from happening the same way. It's funny...I was "researching" Memphis owning the team as a possible idea before his interview...and I actually read the CBA to see if it said anything about ownership. So when he said he hadn't read it, I was floored. I mean, its cool if you are a "laid back, hands off owner" to not read the CBA...but when you are the "I sign the checks, so I make the rules" kind of owner, you might want to brush up on the CBA.

report   
Posted by coolbreeze on August 25, 2010 at 10:01 AM

this is bad. Real Bad.

report   
Posted by nofaithinGriz on August 27, 2010 at 1:31 PM
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-13 of 13

Add a comment

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

© 1996-2012

Contemporary Media
460 Tennessee Street, 2nd Floor | Memphis, TN 38103
Visit our other sites: Memphis Magazine | Memphis Parent | Memphis Business Quarterly
Powered by Foundation