Thursday, July 9, 2009

Etiquette Lesson

How to respond to the mayor's latest announcement.

Posted by John Branston on Thu, Jul 9, 2009 at 4:00 AM

In the unlikely event that Mayor Willie Herenton actually retires or resigns or whatever he wants to call it on July 30th, Hizzoner says there will be a "retirement reception in my honor" in the Hall of Mayors on July 31st from 2 to 4 p.m.

In the even more unlikely event that you should be invited to attend that reception, you should respond properly.

On page 400 of her book Miss Manners' Guide to Excruciatingly Correct Behavior, author Judith Martin offers some advice. The acceptance should say "Mr. and/or Ms. (your name) accepts with pleasure your kind invitation."

Tell him you're coming. Then change your mind.

It's not like there won't be other options. There will be plenty of partying on the day Herenton finally leaves office. Memphians will celebrate in homes, bars, block parties, and restaurants like it's an NBA championship, an NCAA title, and a new millennium.

The question is, will that day ever arrive?

City Council chairman Myron Lowery, who would become the interim mayor, said, "You have to take an individual at his word." But what if the individual already has unresigned twice?

Then "it is up to every individual to make up his own mind," said Lowery, who appears to be resigned to waiting it out. As former city councilman Jack Sammons said, "Unfortunately, he [Herenton] has got the ball, and there's not a lot anyone can do about it."

The mayor who has been in office since 1992 suddenly discovered last week that "there remains some important city business matters that I need additional time to complete."

Then he finally got around to the nature of that important business. The new city charter is "silent on some important issues," like whether or not the mayor pro tem can hold an executive and legislative position at the same time.

"Should the citizens in a special election vote for a mayor and your vacant council seat?" Herenton asked. "We need answers. An immediate friendly lawsuit may be necessary."

There it is. The way out of getting out. A friendly lawsuit filed with a friendly judge so Herenton can say his departure date depends on the court. This sudden concern for the separation of powers is as phony as everything else about Herenton's charade.

"The charter is carefully written," said Steve Wirls, a political science professor at Rhodes College and adviser to the Memphis City Council and Memphis Charter Commission. "Had the authors thought that the chairman of the council would need to vacate his seat in order to become the interim mayor they would have said so clearly. They clearly did not say so."

Wirls said that neither the charter nor the amendments approved by voters in 2008 say anything about the council chairman's seat being "frozen" if he or she becomes mayor pro tem, as city council attorney Allan Wade wrote in an opinion this week.

"I was appalled and angry at Wade's opinion," Wirls said. "It is not a good-faith reading of the charter. It is a convoluted attempt to get around the charter's clarity on this point. He is acting more as Herenton's personal attorney than as a public servant."

In his opinion, Wade wrote:

"Myron Lowery does not lose his seat on the council because of the mandate of the charter that he become mayor pro tem; however, his status as a council member is frozen as of the date he takes the oath of office as mayor pro tem until he returns or becomes mayor."

Wirls said the charter language on the interim mayor is "an exception to take care of an exceptional circumstance." It does not require him to resign or devote his entire time to mayoral duties.

"It says, in plain language, exactly the opposite," Wirls said. "The language clearly states that he will be both at the same time."

The issue is complicated by the fact that Lowery was an elected member of the charter commission that drafted the amendments and is an announced candidate for the job of mayor if there is a special election.

"I have no fight at all with the mayor," Lowery said. "I didn't encourage him to resign."

No, he didn't. Herenton did that all by himself. Not that it makes any difference.

Comments (9) RSS

Showing 1-9 of 9

Add a comment

I love Lowery's naked ambition, a poltico's politico. A charter commission member while on the city council. Possible mayor while on the city council. Possible candidate for city mayor while on the city council acting as city mayor. I think he's got the bases covered. Thank goodness for upcoming term limits.

Posted by tomguleff on July 9, 2009 at 8:34 AM | Report this comment

Don't forget, Term Limits proposed by Lowery himself.
He's done more in his term than Willy's entire career, pro Memphis. Tom Carpenter is more status quo.
If Myron becomes mayor there will be a landslide of reform that will make Memphis move past it's current state of depopulating backwards stupidity and blinkered belligerent non-collaborative attitude.
You have to police public office MORE than the streets, or, not even the streets will be policed.
We've created a culture of ignorance, laziness, belligerence, graft and corruption on a scale only equalled in third world asia.
Memphis is not America.
The feds want to bulldoze it, they've routed the technological highway directly AROUND Memphis and it's pretty obvious by the path it takes that Memphis is being avoided. This city will die if reform doesn't happen.
Mark My Words.

Posted by Bubbah on July 9, 2009 at 8:44 AM | Report this comment

Willy's feighned indignance at a comment never made to him comes off as a lie and stupid, he needs to leave post haste if that's how he's going to continue to talk.
I'd say that LAZY is what you are when you don't apply for federal aid for crime control in the city that was #1 for violent crime at the time he should have done it. Having the Police Chief sandbag stats and hide them in blanket charges and officers NOT writing up reports is no substitute. Lazy is not paying attention to the needs of your city as it slips into that position, not paying attention to it's non-sustainability and doing something, all our problems are like very broadcasted punches, you could see this coming ten years out, why didn't he see it all coming?
I'll tell you why, you can't take care of a city when you are totally focused on your own wallet.

Posted by Bubbah on July 9, 2009 at 8:51 AM | Report this comment

Go Bubbah!

Posted by B on July 9, 2009 at 9:04 AM | Report this comment

I dont think it would be safe to assume that such sweeping reforms could be accomplished by one man, especially when that man seems to be so steeped in the current system. I'm willing to give anyone a fair shake at the position, should it be made vacant. But a good election with public involvement biased on issues not color, followed by broad bipartisan efforts for change, including significant re-evaluation of our current city council, will be a good start for getting this city back on track.

Posted by HollyHollyHello on July 9, 2009 at 9:54 AM | Report this comment

preach it.

Posted by Packrat on July 9, 2009 at 9:59 AM | Report this comment

Well said HollyHollyHello! A big hell to the yeah.

Posted by Phlo on July 9, 2009 at 12:25 PM | Report this comment

Bubbah, Let's not revise history. Term Limits came about through the efforts of the Charter Movement (see John Lunt), not because of Myron. This after a prolonged (court) fight on the term limit provision for the county commission and mayor. Term Limits was a constant desire at almost every public forum that the Charter Commission held. A true believer would not have served 18 years in office, and said, by the way, I am for term limits.

Posted by tomguleff on July 9, 2009 at 1:15 PM | Report this comment

Thank you, it really hurts me to see what our elected officials put this city through on a regular bases. Its time we get someone who will truly work for whats best for the people here and not their own interests.

Posted by HollyHollyHello on July 10, 2009 at 11:08 AM | Report this comment

Add a comment

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Most Commented On

  • Too Much Retail

    Raleigh copes with a struggling mall and "unfair" reputation.
    • Nov 5, 2009
  • Food: The New Football

    Boomer and Tom are getting a run from Paula and Giada.
    • Oct 29, 2009
  • More»
ADVERTISEMENT

Flyer Flashback

Flyer Flashback

To mark the Flyer's 20th anniversary, we're looking back at stories from our first two decades.

Read Story

© 1996-2009

Contemporary Media
460 Tennessee Street, 2nd Floor | Memphis, TN 38103
Visit our other sites: Memphis Magazine | Memphis Parent | Memphis Business Quarterly
Powered by Foundation