The current decade — the "aughts" seems to be the closest we have to a consensus on this — is coming to a close, which is, of course, a great excuse for rampant list-making. I'm starting here with my own Top 50 albums and singles of the decade, counted down over the next month. End-of-decade material on film and local music will follow.

The bulk of the music on this list comes from three general areas — guitar rock of most types and any level of popularity, hip hop both mainstream and indie/underground, and country both Nashville and alt. For me this is where most of the action has been, with strong contributions from three other general areas — R&B/soul, African music, and chart pop. (I lack a better term for what is typically dred ’90s teen pop all grown up.)
There are a few more song-oriented examples of the disparate dance musics I'm ill-informed/gauche enough to still collectively call "techno," but generally I don't know as much about this stuff as I'd like to. If I'd expanded the list out to 100 (and believe me, I was tempted) there may have been token blues (Corey Harris) and jazz (James Carter) entries, but the former has sadly not produced many records that break out (or even deserve to break out) of its niche and the latter is more tangential to the music I care about. There is, I believe, one non-English-language/non-African record on the list. If I had more access and more time it would not be so lonely. As for other genres, I've never been able to drum up much interest in dancehall and I'm lost with metal that has any degree of purity. Anything else is pretty much off my radar.

Finally, where this list will veer from critical consensus the most will be on the presence of mainstream country (which critics don't take seriously enough) and African music (a personal interest most of my demographic ilk don't share) and the relative lack of the tasteful indie rock that outlets like Pitchfork Media and NPR have helped turn into cultural status items for educated, liberal white people. The way I heard the past decade, semi-obscure songwriters like Amy Rigby, Todd Snider, and Bobby Pinson had a lot more to say about the world than Beck, Wilco's Jeff Tweedy, or Radiohead's Thom Yorke.
Those caveats out of the way, here we go. I'll be counting down albums and singles in pairs at the rate of a new post every day or two (25 total) throughout the next month:
50.

What I wrote last year still applies:
There are suddenly a surfeit of artists tapping into '60s and '70s soul sounds, but former Tony Toni Tone singer Raphael Saadiq has been working in the vein for 20 years now: He's not a tribute artist; he's a practitioner. And the nonstop groove, compositional detail, and sometimes surprising songwriting ("Keep Marchin'" the campaign theme Curtis Mayfield wasn't around to write; "Sometimes" a family meditation of Smokey Robinson-level grace) on The Way I See It is the closest he — or anyone else — has been to the muse since his old band's 1996 swan song, House of Music.
Song sample: "Sometimes"
Single: "On My Block" — Scarface (2002)
The former Geto Boy's guided tour of his hood. I'm a sucker for hooking a beat up to a piano loop and converting it into hip-hop form. The official video:
49.

The most recent record on the list. My review from last month:
Brad Paisley will never be considered a major artist by listeners who insist modern country be anachronistic or constipated to be taken seriously; who think marriage, work, and parenting unworthy pop-song subjects; who can't stomach a little schmaltz. But the multi-threat singer/songwriter/guitarist is a master craftsman on a big-time roll, one that stays on the upswing with this career-best seventh album. American Saturday Night is remarkable in part for being everything country music's target demo doesn't seem to be these days: Friendly, optimistic, pluralistic. The third-verse swerve and closing exhortation of "Welcome to the Future" leaves a lump in your throat long after you know what's coming, and it's made more meaningful in the hands of a country-music megastar from Obama-resistant West Virginia. And when that song bumps up against a testimonial to the value of a good marriage while the lead-off cultural diversity anthem is matched by a nimble, lived-in testimonial to the value of a good fishing trip, you start to believe that mainstream country's most skilled musician — his own guitar rarely letting the music flag — might be able to carry his audience along with him on this journey.
Song sample: "Welcome to the Future"
Single: "High Cost of Living" — Jamey Johnson (2008)
The new face of outlaw. One-Liner of the Decade candidate: "That Southern Baptist parking lot is where I'd go to smoke my pot."
Showing 1-8 of 8
I'm interested to see how this list pans out. Maybe its a bit early to critique the critera, but I, however, did not experience this decade of music as one of guitar rock and alt/mainstream country. Hip hop I'll give you (Stankonia should be 1 or 1a on any "decade's best" list) with massive contributions by Jay-Z, Ghostface, Clipse, Lil Wayne etc.... I may be premature, but your caveat about the list above ignores what have been the biggest developments in popular music over the past decade - the emergence(s) of electronic, dance, techno, dub, etc... music for the lack of better terms. You characterized Pitchfork as selling indie street cred through "tasteful indie rock". Look at Pitchfork's recent 500 greatest songs of the decade list and you'll see one "indie rock" song in the top 20 ("The Rat" by the Walkmen). My decade in music started with Radiohead (who's message is through the music, not the lyrics) and the landscape changing "Idioteque". Again, your list is your list, but, since you are a music critic, to dismiss Tweedy and Yorke, who made major contributions to the decade's musical landscape both directly and through their broader influence, to embrace African music, singer songwriters and popular country seems a tad different for difference's sake.
Becton: A few things:
1) I know Pitchfork has branched out in recent years, but its initial rise to prominence early in the decade was very much tied to the canonization of a certain brand of collegiate indie rock, much of which I like, but the critical elevation of which is rooted in the cultural biases of those doing the elevating.
2) If you want to claim goings-on in the techno/dance world as the biggest developments in popular music over the past decade, you can make that case. But it is not exactly a universal belief. It's still a subculture, and it's not mine. Perhaps to my detriment. Though, as I intimated, those genres are not shut out on my list.
3) You basically make my point for me at the end. Who says that arty alt-rock like Radiohead and Wilco is the center of good pop music and that liking "African music, singer songwriters, and popular country" as much or more is somehow an act of willful contrarianism? I understand that view is prevalent, but I didn't get to vote on it. It's basically the result of the same kind of critical/cultural biases that once made Pink Floyd more worthy of reflection than Sam & Dave. Smart people can disagree on these things, and I do. (And, incidentally, I don't dismiss these people. 50 records over an entire decade is a short list, and they didn't make mine.)
Mad Merc: Two cornerstone musical genres that appeal to millions of people???? WTF????
It's his list and he can put whatever he likes on it. I was just expressing my dislike of country, although I will say of the cut and paste format that pervades the modern country genre, Brad Paisley is a stand out performer/song writer that goes his own way. As for hip-hop, rap, or what ever it's called, it's not music. Never has been, never will be. And it's definitely not a cornerstone of anything.
It would be hard to discount the techno scene I would think, considering that some of the DJs play to bigger crowds in Europe than most bands play to here in the States. I like it, but don't follow it, if that makes sense.
Anyway, I'm looking forward to the rest of the list and hopefully discovering some new tunes for the collection. Still can't stand hip hop though!
i know it's pretty closed-minded of me, but i've had a real hard time with most anything mainstream coming out of Nashville pretty much since '82 or thereabouts.
i think hip-hop still has a couple more golden-eras to go, but it's certainly on the downswing at the moment imo.
mad_merc--I'm interested in what elements of hip-hop make it "not music" in your opinion.
When I saw that the Pitchfork list had only that Walkmen song in its top 20 from among indie rock hits, I thought they were trying to be different for different's sake.
When I was a freshman in college, I knew a guy who came to school with about 100 slightly lame Top 40 CD's. He got into smoking pot and miraculously he came back from Christmas break with literally about 250 jam band CD's. This was pre-CD burners and iPod's so this was a result of major purchasing straight from central casting. I always thought that guy was being different for different's sake b/c he had no interest in the music, just the image of the music.
I'm pretty sure Herrington isn't embracing popular country music for the image.
Comments (8) RSS